German Village Society » Commission

Commission Agenda 12/6/11

admin — Mon, 05 Dec 2011 19:17:18 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

December 6, 2011

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

Applicants or their representatives must attend this hearing. If applicants are absent, it is likely that the application will be continued until the Commission’s next hearing. If you have any questions, please call the city’s Historic Preservation Office at 645-8620 or 645-7920. A Sign Language Interpreter to “Sign” this hearing will be made available for anyone with a need for this service. Sign language interpreters must be schedule by calling 645-8620 or TDD 645-3293 at least forty-eight (48) hours prior to the scheduled hearing.

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, December 27, 2011.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, January 3, 2012.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, November 1, 2011.

V. SWEAR IN STAFF

VI. STAFF APPROVALS

VII. PUBLIC FORUM

VIII. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

HOLDOVERS

1. 11-10-16

245 Jackson Street

Tom Cook Company, Ltd. (Applicant) Julianna Bull (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs.

Replace Slate Roof

• Remove deteriorated slate roof.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged and deteriorated metal valleys with new metal valleys of appropriate dimension, as necessary. Valleys are to be smooth not a “W” channel to maintain the appropriate historic appearance and profile.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] CertainTeed Carriage House (dimensional) [ ] Stonegate Gray

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

2. 11-10-18

67 East Deshler Avenue

Susan D. Rector (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a site plan and photograph.

Replace Sidewalk

• Replace deteriorated concrete sidewalk, service walk and driveway with new concrete walks in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• New public sidewalk and driveway are to have clay paver soldier course as a border along both edges, per submitted plan.

• Corner is to be concrete with truncated texture inlay, per City Code and ADA regulations.

3. 11-10-21

797 South Sixth Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Craig Kent & Erin Crotty (Owner)

An application has been submitted with site plan, building plan, elevations and material specifications.

Two Story Addition

• Construct new 538 sq. ft. two story frame addition on east (rear) side of two-and-a-half story frame house with a two story connector, per submitted plans.

• Siding is to be Lamerite composite shingles on second story west and south walls, tinted (“Warmtone” N60), four inch by sixteen inch (4” x 16”) concrete block on the west, north and south first story walls, and Hardie Panel, painted to match the slate, with Fry reglets in joints and on corners on the north wall.

• Roof is to be rubber membrane roofing.

• Windows are to be fixed, casement and awning style Universal brand metal windows.

• Windows on connector are to be fixed with sandblasted glass.

• Doors on west elevation are to be clad slider doors.

4. 11-11-18

524 South Third Street

Joshua Aalberg & Sarah Bullock (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and a site plan. The applicant has asked to continue to the January 3, 2012 meeting.

Install Pool

• Install new eight by thirty foot (8’x 30’) in-ground pool in rear yard.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:15PM

5. 11-11-20

579 South Grant Avenue

Mike Titus (Applicant/Owner)

This application has been divided into items “a” and “b” An application has been submitted with photographs and a site plan.

11-11-20a

Variances Requested

• Reduce width of driveway to 8’7” (10’ minimum required).

• Reduce side yard setback to 1’ (3’ required).

• Reduce side yard allowance.

11-11-20b

579 South Grant Avenue

Install New Driveway and Curb cut

• Install single car driveway, eight feet, seven inches wide by thirty-three feet long (8’7” x 33’), per submitted plans.

• Driveway to be paved with Holland Severe Weather Red Paver Bricks, laid over compacted crushed stone and masonry sand; pattern is to match existing sidewalk.

• Cut existing sandstone curb for driveway apron.

• Remove one six inch (6”) dia. tree and one four foot (4’) tall bush.

• Move existing wood fence and gate back ten feet (10’) toward the rear of the property.

VARIANCE RECOMMENDATIONS

6. 11-12-24

745 South Third Street

Smith & Hale, LLC (Applicant) American Blue Ribbon Holdings, LLC (Owner)

An application, photographs, a Statement of Hardship, Council Variance Application and floor plans have been submitted. Zoning restrictions will be triggered by the expansion of the Restaurant into the adjacent building, which is currently a single family residence.

Variances Requested

• C.C. 3312.49: Minimum number of parking spaces – reduce from the required 11 spaces to 0.

• C.C. 3332.037: R-2F residential district – to permit restaurant and office use in the residential district.

NEW APPLICATIONS

7. 11-12-25

369 Jackson Street

Renovations Unlimited (Applicant) Pat & Dave Hopcraft (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs.

Remove Non-functional Chimney

• Remove badly deteriorated non-functional, non-original wood frame and stucco chimney on the main roof.

• Cover opening with sheathing, slate tile and metal ridge roll to match existing.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30PM

8. 11-12-26

693 City Park Avenue

Renovations Unlimited (Applicant) Barb & Ron Hagan (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, site plan and elevations.

Demolish and Rebuild Addition

• Amend previously approved COA #11-6-17, issued on June 6, 2011 for renovations to kitchen and three season room addition to allow full demolition of addition and rebuild to match dimensions and roof form of previously existing structure, per submitted plans.

9. 11-12-27

571-575 South Third Street

Timothy J. McGrath (Applicant) 571-575 South Third Street Condominium Association (Owner)

An application has been submitted with a site plan, photographs, and arborist’s assessment.

Tree Removal

• To avoid further damage to the public sidewalk and to insure public safety, remove three declining sycamore trees in the tree lawn.

• Tree removal to be done in accordance with standard industry practices to insure the safety of all neighboring properties and any/all workers involved.

• Remove the stump below grade to prevent new growth

• Haul away all debris.

• Plant three new trees in the same general area as the trees that are to be removed.

• The species of the new trees is to be the small cherry tree, Prunus incise x P.campanulata (as listed in the German Village Society’s Recommended Tree Types).

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, concrete public and service sidewalks, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

10. 11-12-28

568-574 South Fifth Street

Jeff Cramblitt (Applicant) John Allen (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs.

Install Downspouts

• Install approximately thirty-eight feet (38’) of new, four inch (4”), round galvanized downspouts, running along the south side of the building at 568-570 South Fifth, and along the north and south sides of the building at 572-574 South Fifth Street.

• All downspouts will be connected to existing downspouts on the rear of the buildings and lead to new drains at the front corners.

• Downspouts are to be anchored into the mortar on the walls and painted to match brick color as closely as possible.

Install New Drains

• Temporarily remove portions of the existing brick sidewalk and install 4” PVC drain tile below the grade.

• Cut curb in three locations, as shown on submitted plans, for drain installation and then repair curb with concrete or suitable material.

• Restore brick sidewalk, using existing bricks, to match existing conditions, with same brick pattern, slope and a flat, even surface. All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:45PM

11. 11-12-29

836 Pearl Street

Nathan Fisher (Applicant) D&S Properties (Owner)

An application has been submitted with

Replace Slate Roof

• Remove deteriorated slate roofing on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

12. 11-12-30

921 Mohawk Street

William C. Bigelow (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a photograph and cutsheet.

Replace Garage Doors

• Replace deteriorated, side opening garage doors with new steel overhead door in a similar design to existing doors, per submitted cutsheet.

• New door is to be painted to mimic stained wood.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:00PM

13. 11-12-31

689 South Third Street

Damon Baker (Applicant) Boyd & Renate Fackler (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, a site plan, building plan and elevations.

• Construct one-story, frame addition, with connector, on rear of one-and-a-half story brick cottage, per submitted plans.

• Add covered porch on south side of existing cottage.

• Construct two car frame garage in rear of property.

14. 11-12-32

874 South Fifth Street

Brian Tuckerman (Applicant) Barbi Tuckerman (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and window cutsheets.

Replace Windows

• Replace sashes on twelve (12) deteriorated windows on the house with new Jeld-Wen, all wood, sash kits, to match existing window configurations.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:15PM

15. 11-12-33

1075-1077 City Park Avenue

John E. Lamotte (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. New shingles to be CertainTeed Landmark in “Weathered Wood” color.

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

16. 11-12-23a

866 South Pearl Street

Michelle Murphy (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs. Application #11-12-23 has been divided into item ‘a’ for German Village Commission review under New Business, and item ‘b’ for Staff Approval under Staff Approved items.

Replace Windows

• Replace deteriorated wood windows on the house with new wood windows.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION

17. 11-12-34

170 Thurman Avenue

Mark & Keriann Ours (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs.

Repair Windows

• Repair ten (10), 1-over-1, historic wood windows.

• Remove single pane glazing and install insulated glass.

• Remove non-historic shutters.

• Remove storm windows.

Replace front door glass

• Remove non-historic stained glass in front door and replace with clear glass (half light).

Restore Lintels

• Remove scroll work from stone lintels on front elevation.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:30PM

18. 11-12-35

210 Thurman Avenue & 1120 Jaeger Street

John Behal – Behal, Sampson, Dietz (Applicant) Rebecca Milnes (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, site plan, building plans and elevations.

Site Alterations

• Install new concrete steps, sidewalk, landings, sloped sidewalk and wrought iron handrails for the north and east entrance doors.

• Install new concrete patio, per submitted plans.

• Install new planting bed along east property line.

Building Alterations

• On west elevation:

• Remove existing scupper box and downspout. Infill scupper opening in parapet wall with brick to match existing as closely as possible.

• Remove existing garage door on west elevation.

• Install new painted metal chimney for interior fireplace on north, east and west.

• On the north elevation, install new wood transom windows above existing double hung windows.

• Install new entrance canopies on north and east elevations.

• Install new lighting on north and east elevations.

• Install new sun tunnels on roof.

• Install new skylights on roof.

• On the east elevation:

• Remove existing concrete steps at previously infilled door opening.

• On east elevation, remove existing window and modify masonry opening for new wood and glass patio door.

• On east elevation, install new scupper, aluminum gutter and downspout, and install a new emergency scupper through the parapet wall.

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW

19. 11-12-36

150 East Beck Street

John Behal – Behal, Sampson, Dietz (Applicant) David & Amy Smith (Owner)

Rehabilitation

• Restore door to an opening on Beck Street (currently a window).

• Replace non-original windows with aluminum clad, SDL, 2-over-2, wood windows.

• Remove storm windows.

• Remove c. 1976 first floor addition in rear.

• Replace c. 1976 greenhouse addition and replace with traditional dormer.

• Replace two (2) c. 1976 second floor, French doors with casement windows; replace two (2) c. 1976 first floor French doors with new French doors.

• Add two (2) square windows on west façade.

• Add skylights, per submitted plans.

• Raise roof on garage.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:45PM

20. 11-12-37

Third Street between Livingston and Reinhard Avenue

German Village Society (Applicant) City of Columbus (Owner)

Streetscape Improvements

• Modify overhead utility lines by consolidating wires and eliminating cross wires; eliminate all signs and lights from utility poles.

• Convert street surface to brick, from curb to curb; add a dedicated 6’ wide bike lane on west side between curb and parking;

• Convert all curbs to limestone.

• Convert all sidewalks to brick, using the Guidelines’ recommendation for type of brick, patters and paving methods.

• Install dedicated poles for street lighting on both sides of the street

• Install new poles for street and parking signs, per Third Street Master Plan developed by the German Village Society.

21. 11-12-38

40 Stewart Avenue (Stewart Elementary School)

Hardlines Design Company (Applicant) Columbus City Schools (Owner)

An application has also been submitted to the Brewery District Commission for the portion of this project that encompasses 966 South High Street, which includes a proposal to demolish the Maennerchor Building.

Conceptual Review

• Rehabilitation of school building, to include replacement of non-original windows, repair of exterior stone details, repair and repointing of brick masonry, and replacement of asphalt/EPDM roofing.

• New 16,500 sq. ft. addition to school building.

• Closure and redirection of a portion of Pearl Street.

• Landscaping

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 11-12-1

745-747 South Sixth Street

Mike Leitwein, Gutters & Spouts, Inc. (Applicant) Agnes Dorn (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-1, 745-747 South Sixth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the front and rear porch roofing, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] CertainTeed Carriage House (dimensional) [ ] Stonegate Gray

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

Re-roof Over

• Secure existing roofing on garage; remove all debris. Cut out all bubbles, wrinkles and leaking areas; patch with 30 lb. felt.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Color:

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-12-2

377 East Jackson Street

Dehlco Construction Services (Applicant) Mike & Hilary Talis (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-2, 377 East Jackson Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Eave, Soffit & Fascia Repair

• Repair and or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood eave soffit and fascia on all elevations as necessary with new wood of exact same profile and dimension; like-for-like.

• Prime all bare and new wood with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications; finish coat to match existing color.

• 11-12-3

626 Mohawk Street

Kevin Smith (Applicant) Marc Spindelman (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-3, 626 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install Pergola

• Install nine by thirteen by eight foot high (9’W x 13’L x 8’H) cedar pergola in rear yard, per submitted site plan.

Install Bluestone Pavers

• Remove existing bricks below pergola and in a separate eleven by eleven foot (11’ x 11’) section of rear yard, as indicated on submitted site plan, and install bluestone pavers with mortared joints.

• 11-12-4

208 Reinhard Avenue

Thomas Connors (Applicant) Gale Shamansky (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-4, 208 Reinhard Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Porch Flooring

• Remove and dispose of all existing, deteriorated flooring; pull all nails from, and inspect condition of, existing joists to insure structural integrity.

• Replace any deteriorated, rotted joists with new wood joists of dimensions.

• Install [ ] 1″ x 3″ or [ ] 1″ x 6″ tongue and groove, yellow pine, porch decking.

• Blind nail with galvanized finish nails only.

• Allow a 1 1/2″ minimum to 2 1/2″ maximum flooring overhang on all outside edges.

• Install exterior grade, quarter-round moulding to band board fascia, tight against all flooring overhang.

• Prime on all sides with porch floor enamel thinned with appropriate material prior to installation. After installation, topcoat with same porch floor enamel according to manufacturer’s specifications for finish coat.

• Paint color for final coat is to match existing, or if changed, a paint chip is to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

• 11-12-5

1131 & 1133 City Park Avenue

City Park Condo Association, Patrick King & Mary Hatem (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-5, 1131 & 1133 City Park Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install New Rubber Roof

• Install new E. P. D. M. rubber over existing membrane roofing in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.

• 11-12-6

175 East Whittier Street

Christina & Chad Pannunzio (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-6, 175 East Whittier Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install New Furnace Vents

• Install new venting for furnace on the west wall of the house, per submitted plans.

• Vents are to be two inch (2” dia.) PVC pipes. The exhaust pipe is to extend from the wall three inches (3”) and elbow down three inches (3”); the intake pipe will extend out and have a “T”.

• All exposed pipe on the exterior shall be painted to match the existing siding.

• 11-12-7

845 South Fifth Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-7, 845 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA #10-1-6, 845 South Fifth Street, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Second renewal. Current COA #11-1-6 expires: 12-23-11.

Approve Application #10-1-6, 845 South Fifth Street, as submitted:

• Final approval for rear two-story frame addition to existing two-story brick residence.

• Exterior materials to be: 4” exposure wood lap siding, wood trim boards, asphalt shingle from Approved Shingle List, 6” ogee gutters with 3” downspouts, split-face block foundation, wood windows and french doors by Marvin. Windows to have 7/8” SDLs with spacer bars.

MOTION: Wang-Durst/Thiell (7-0-0) APPROVED.

• 11-12-8

308 Jackson Street

Jess Howard Electric Company (Applicant) Lynda Sudderberg (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-8, 308 Jackson Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install Generator

• Install a 26” W x 28”H x 38” L backup generator in the east side yard, behind existing solid wood fence.

• 11-12-9

861 South Fifth Street

Richard Zapor (Applicant) George Laurey (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-9, 861 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install New Storm Windows

• Install new, low profile, metal storm windows: on one south side, second story, double hung window and on three fixed basement windows.

• New storm windows to be installed inside the existing window frame.

• Storm window color to match the primary trim color as closely as possible.

• Double caulk to provide air-tight installation on top and sides. Do not caulk breather holes.

• Horizontal bar on new storm window to align with horizontal sash bar on existing second story window. Basement storm windows are to be single sash, of the same dimensions as the existing window sash.

• Storm windows to operate smoothly.

• All work to be in accordance with the performance manual.

• 11-12-10

32-34 East Kossuth Street

Connie Garcia (Applicant) Richard Chang (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-10, 32-34 East Kossuth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the garage and porches on the house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint colors for final coat are to be “Black Forest Green” for the garage doors, and “Equestrian Gray” for the porches as well as the trim on garage.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-12-11

210 Thurman Avenue

Tarini Cement Contracting (Applicant) Rebecca Milnes (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-11, 210 Thurman Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, concrete public and service sidewalks and curbs, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete walk and curb in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

• 11-12-12

800 South Lazelle Street

Renovations Unlimited (Applicant) Lenita & Tom Pepper (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-12, 800 South Lazelle Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Re-roof Over

• Secure existing roofing–remove all debris. Cut out all bubbles, wrinkles and leaking areas; patch with 30 lb. felt.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Color:

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-12-13

724 Macon Alley

Jennifer Arthur (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-13, 724 Macon Alley, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house and the garage for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Wood shakes to be stained to match porch color (“Chesapeake”). Finish coat for trim is to be Sherwin Williams “Relaxed Khaki” (SW 6149) for the trim and “Universal Khaki” (SW 6150) for the garage.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-12-14

49 East Sycamore Street

Thomas D. Evans (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-14, 49 East Sycamore Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair Exterior Door

• Make any/all necessary repairs to the existing, contributing, wooden door on the front entrance, per industry standards.

• All new wood to be of exact same profile and dimension as the original door panels, stiles, and rails; like-for-like.

• Paint color is to match existing or new paint color chips are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.

• 11-12-15

821 South Fifth Street

Brian Connor (Applicant) Matthew Fenwick (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-15, 821 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Paint wood trim, gutters, windows and doors on the house to match existing color scheme. Any new colors are to be submitted with paint color chips to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat paint color is to be Sherwin Williams “Sticks & Stones” (SW 7503).

• Any previously unpainted masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-12-16

137-141 East Whittier Street

Dan & Michele Lavon (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-16, 137-141 East Whittier Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Stair Handrail

• Prior to the installation of the new handrails, examine the existing front porch service steps and perform any/all necessary site work to insure a stable and level foundation for the existing steps with appropriate slope for water drainage.

• Remove existing pipe rail on front porches of both units.

• Install new black metal handrail on both front porches and steps in accordance with all applicable Columbus Building Codes. The style of new railing is to be Fortin Welding & Mfg. Inc. brochure, Model RSS, per submitted plans.

• 11-12-17

206 Blenkner Street

Clayton J. Toth (Applicant) Louis Maani (Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-17, 206 Blenkner Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install New Storm Door

• Install a new, full light, aluminum storm door on both front and rear entrances.

• Cut sheet and color chip for the new storm door to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to installation of the door.

• 11-12-18

658 South Grant Avenue

Jaci Elston (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-18, 658 South Grant Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] CertainTeed Carriage House (dimensional) [ ] Stonegate Gray

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-12-19

196 Reinhard Avenue

Joyce Politi (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-19, 196 Reinhard Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Siding

• Amend previously issued COA #11-10-14, 196 Reinhard Avenue, staff approved on September 22, 2011 to include siding replacement.

• Remove all deteriorated, rotted wood siding on the entire north side of the carriage house and on the south side from the ground up to the height of the window aprons.

• Replace with new, wood, tongue and groove siding, with V groove, to match existing as closely as possible, per submitted sample.

• 11-12-20

1000 Jaeger Street

Larry Lehring (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-20, 1000 Jaeger Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, concrete public and service sidewalks, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

• 11-12-21

1004 Jaeger Street

Sean Embry (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-21, 1004 Jaeger Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, concrete public and service sidewalks, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

• 11-12-22

861 City Park Avenue

Allen Card (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-22, 861 City Park Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair Box Gutters

• Examine all box gutters on the house and make any repairs and/or replace the existing box gutter system on all elevations with new materials of appropriate dimension and profile.

• Reline with new copper, terne metal, galvanized metal, or E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes.

• Install new, round, galvanized metal downspouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.

• Examine the existing storm water drainage system for soundness and proper function. Make any/all necessary repairs to the existing storm sewer tile system to assure proper drainage away from the foundations of this and neighboring properties. If deemed necessary, install a French drain system or similar, appropriate drainage system in accordance with all applicable City Building Codes and industry standards.

• 11-12-23b

866 South Pearl Street

Michelle Murphy (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-12-23b, 866 South Pearl Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] CertainTeed Carriage House (dimensional) [ ] Stonegate Gray

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

IX. OLD BUSINESS

X. NEW BUSINESS

XI. ADJOURNMENT

Commission Agenda 09/13/11

jgraichen — Wed, 07 Sep 2011 02:33:44 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

September 13, 2011

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, September 27, 2011.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, October 4, 2011.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, August 2, 2011.

V. STAFF APPROVALS

VI. PUBLIC FORUM

• City of Columbus Public Health – ArtWalk Signs

• City of Columbus Recreation and Parks Department – Schiller Park playground equipment replacement.

VII. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

HOLDOVERS

1. 11-8-8

897 South Third Street

Jason Bainum (Applicant) Mike Ferris (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs of the building and renderings of the proposed signs. Applicant has consulted with staff.

Install Signs

• Apply two (2) business twelve inch high by thirty inch wide (12” h x 30” w) signs to existing awning; one sign on east side be above entrance; one sign on north side of the awning, as shown on submitted renderings.

• Apply one sign on the window of the main entry door.

2. 11-8-10

804 Jaeger Street

Russell E. Blanks (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and a site plan.

Relocate Air-conditioner Unit

• Relocate air-conditioner unit from rear yard to front yard next to front porch, as shown on submitted site plan.

• Air-conditioner to be screened with vegetation.

3. 11-8-11

711 South Grant Avenue

Ellen Hinton (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a landscape plan, photographs, a survey, fence details.

Landscaping

• Remove overgrown vegetation and debris from narrow planting strip on east side of house.

• Bury downspout drains and regrade soil to allow proper runoff.

• Install curbing of salvaged Ohio limestone, installed in accordance with Columbus City Codes and industry standards.

• Install brick paver walkway leading to entrance.

• Add new plantings, per submitted landscape plan.

Add Fence

• Install three foot high (3’ h) wrought iron fencing at the edge of planting strip, per submitted landscape plan and fence detail.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30PM

4. 11-8-12

870 South Fifth Street

Amy Bonomi (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a roof assessment.

Replace Slate Roof

• Remove all slate roofing on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner

from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red”

or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

Repair Stop Gutters

• Examine all stop gutters on the main roof and make any repairs and/or replace the existing stop gutter system

on all elevations with new materials of appropriate dimension and profile.

• Reline with new copper, terne metal, galvanized metal, or E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes.

• Install new, round, galvanized metal downspouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.

NEW APPLICATIONS

5. 11-9-16

37 East Deshler Avenue

Charles & Carol Mix (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and a cutsheet.

Replace Side Door

• Remove full light wood side door.

• Replace with half light fiberglass door, with internal mini-blind, per submitted cut sheet.

6. 11-9-17

785 City Park Avenue

Jon Buskirk (Applicant) Dennis Giglio & Michael Thompson (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, drawings and a site plan.

Rear Addition

• Construct a fifteen foot ten inch by thirteen foot four inch (15’10” x 13’4”), three season porch addition on the rear (west) side of existing house, per submitted plans.

• Addition to have a flat membrane roof, wood trim to match existing, board and batten siding on the south elevation, and smooth wood lap siding on the north and west elevations to match existing on the house.

• Eight (8) windows on the addition to be aluminum clad casement windows with fixed transoms, per submitted cutsheet.

• Door on the addition to be full light wood door with fixed transom.

• Window on west side of the house to be replaced with two aluminum clad wood French doors, per submitted cutsheet.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:45 PM

7. 11-9-18

1071 City Park Avenue

Vinh-Truyen Nguyen (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and a site plan. Work has been completed.

Pergola

• Build new twelve foot by eighteen foot (12’ x 18’), ten foot high (10’ h) wood pergola in rear yard.

• Install flagstone patio in rear yard, under pergola, with three inch (3”) joints filled with small loose pebbles.

8. 11-9-19

943-945 City Park Avenue

Phil Barger (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and product brochures.

Replace Garage Doors

• Remove deteriorated, non-original garage doors on four car garage.

• Replace with new seven foot high (7’ h), overhead garage doors, per submitted cutsheet.

• Remove asphalt shingle siding above garage doors; replace with wood six inch or eight inch (6” or 8”) wood lap siding and wood trim to match original door head height (8’).

9. 11-9-20

585 City Park Avenue

Terry Cordle (Applicant) Don Lamb (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and drawings.

Replace Driveway Apron

• Replace existing concrete apron with new concrete apron with lower slope.

• Relay existing bricks to meet height of new apron and create a smooth, gradual slope to existing sidewalk grade, per submitted plans.

• The concrete approach will be extended from two feet to four to five feet; the curb will match existing.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION

10. 11-9-21

248 East Whittier Street

Amanda Gallo (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and product brochure.

Replace Windows

• Replace deteriorated and missing one-over-one windows on the house with new all wood Jeld-wen, one-over-one windows.

• Remove storm windows.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:15 PM

11. 11-9-22

317 Blenker Street

Jim D. Centers (Applicant) Rosealee Goodfeld (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and a site plan.

Install Concrete Driveway

• Replace partial service walk at side of house with ten foot by fourteen foot (10’ x 14’) concrete driveway.

• Add gravel to existing off street parking area.

12. 11-9-23

563 South Grant Avenue

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Kim McCormick (Owner)

An application has been submitted with drawings and photographs. Project has been reviewed conceptually previously.

Rear Addition

• Construct new two story rear addition, per submitted plans.

• Roof to be asphalt shingles, per approved list, with metal ridge roll painted Tinner’s Red.

• Siding to be four inch (4”) smooth lap siding.

• Windows to be all wood Jeld-wen or Kolbe.

• All siding and trim colors to match existing on house

• Gutters to be half round on north side and K-style on south side.

13. 11-9-24

862 Mohawk Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Riley/Cornelis (Owner)

An application has been submitted with plans and photographs.

Install Skylights

• Install new twenty-one and a half inch by thirty-eight and a half inch (21½” x 38½“) Velux skylight on south roof slope, per submitted plans and specifications.

14. 11-9-25

900 South Third Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Sue Fauber & Tammi Quinn (Owner)

An application has been submitted with plans and photographs.

Landscaping

• Remove tree on east side of building (rear yard).

• Install low stone rubble wall to match existing neighboring wall.

• Install new six foot high (6’ h), board on board wood fence along Whittier Street, to match neighboring fence.

Extend Parking Lot

• Add sixteen inches (16”) of asphalt paving to existing parking lot.

15. 11-9-26

994 Jaeger Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Carlos & Suzie Alvarez (Owner)

An application has been submitted with plans and photographs.

Replace Porch Canopy

• Remove non-original front door porch cover and replace with new four foot by seven foot (4’ x 7’) canopy, per submitted drawings.

• Remove front door slab and glass transom and install new full height four panel, three foot by eight foot (3’x 8’) wood door, stained to match existing.

STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS

16. 11-9-27

982 Jaeger Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Groat/Neal (Owner)

An application has been submitted with plans and photographs.

Landscaping

• Install new bluestone pavers over existing concrete porch floor in rear yard, per submitted plans and specifications.

17. 11-9-28

263 East Whittier Street

Barcelona Restaurant (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a description and drawings. The proposed tent has previously been reviewed and approved as submitted for the past five years.

Install Temporary Patio Enclosure Tent

• Install a fifteen by thirty foot (15’ x 30’) frame tent on existing enclosed patio space, per submitted plans.

• Tent is to be installed as a temporary structure and will remain in place from September 30, 2011 to January 3, 2012.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 11-9-1

491-493 South Third Street

Brian Testerman (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-1, 491-493 South Third Street, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-9-2

877 Mohawk Street

Cheryl Brown (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-2, 877 Mohawk Street, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Install New Roof

• Remove any/all metal roofing on the rear shed roof down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Examine the shed rafter system and make any/all necessary structural repairs in accordance with industry standards and all applicable Columbus City Building Codes.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Examine the slope of the original shed roof structure and install the appropriate roofing material and underlayment per industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and all applicable Columbus City Building Codes. Color of roofing material to be submitted to the Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, in consultation with the German Village Commission, prior to installation.

• Replace any/all damaged and deteriorated metal flashing with new metal flashing of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• 11-9-3

756 South Third Street

Urban Order Architecture (Applicant) Dan Berglund (Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-3, 756 South Third Street, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Repair/Replace Stucco

• Remove all deteriorated stucco on the front (west) wall, as needed. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace with new stucco to match existing, like for like, with identical finish texture.

• Patch and restore cracked stucco on north, south and east walls house, to match original texture and appearance.

• 11-9-4

610 South Grant Avenue

Brad Arensberg, Bradley Builders, Inc. (Applicant) David Tomola (Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-4, 610 South Grant Avenue, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-9-5

77 Frankfort Street

Dan & Mona Szente (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-5, 77 Frankfort Street, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish paint colors to be Benjamin Moore “Hale Navy” (HC-154) for the body and “Simply White” (2143-70) for the trim.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-9-6

85 Concord Place

Charles Browne (Applicant) Bruce Ingram (Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-6, 85 Concord Place, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat to match existing colors.

• Any previously unpainted masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• Remove rear awning for project and reinstall when complete.

• Power washing the wood siding is not included in this approval. Applicant must contact the Historic Preservation Office staff to schedule a patch test and demonstrate that the proposed method of power washing is safe for the existing historic material.

• 11-9-7

711 South Grant Avenue

Ellen Hinton (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-7, 711 South Grant Avenue, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Install Rear Fence

• Install new wrought iron style fence with a gate in the rear yard, per submitted plans.

• Fence shall be five feet high (5’ h), Fortin Iron Works style F49S with 9-X finials on the top row of pickets only, non-decorative posts, and painted black.

• 11-9-8

180 Reinhard Avenue

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Schiller Park, LLC (Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-8, 180 Reinhard Avenue, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Rebuild Brick Sidewalk

• Remove deteriorated brick sidewalk.

• Rebuild base and reinstall sidewalk using existing bricks laid in the same herringbone pattern. If any bricks are too deteriorated to be reused, replace with new bricks to match in size and color (Glen Gery # 53DD).

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

• 11-9-9

849 City Park Avenue

Robert Mullinax (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-9, 849 City Park Avenue, as submitted with clarifications as noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat paint colors to be as follows: Valspar “Swiss Coffee” (7002-16) for the trim and Valspar “Gray Exposé” (5007-2A) for the second story dormer siding

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-9-10

601 South Third Street

Andrea Mulholland (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-10, 601 South Third Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Update Sign Graphics

• Add name of new associate to existing wall sign, to match existing, using the same font and color.

• 11-9-11

590 City Park Avenue

Meghan & Nick Cavalaris (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-11, 590 City Park Avenue as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA#08-12-7, 590 City Park Avenue, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Expired: 11-25-09.

APPROVED SPECIFICATIONS:

• Repaint the exterior per submitted Benjamin Moore paint schedule: Body Color = “Victorian Garden” (#1531); Primary Accent = (#1533)

• Replace the existing front door with new, four-panel, wood door as per Columbus Wood Products Style #106 submitted.

• Install new, exterior light fixture at front entry as per submitted brochure.

• 11-9-12

119-123 Willow Street

Hashem Shkoukani (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-12, 119-123 Willow Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-9-13

373-375 Jackson Street

Michele Lavon (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-13, 373-375 Jackson Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-9-14

306-308 Blenker Street

Michele Lavon (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-14, 306-308 Blenker Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-9-15

213 East Beck Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Jeff Smith & Vijaya Iyer (Owner)

Approve Application #11-9-15, 213 East Beck Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat color schedule to be as submitted: Benjamin Moore “Fatigue Green” (2140-10) for the door slabs, shutters and window sashes; “Dark Olive” (2140-30) for the siding; “Storm Cloud Gray” (2140-40) for all other trim.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

VIII. OLD BUSINESS

IX. NEW BUSINESS

X. ADJOURNMENT

Commission Agenda 08/02/11

jgraichen — Wed, 27 Jul 2011 02:19:25 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

August 2, 2011

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), August 30, 2011.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, September 13, 2011.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, July 12, 2011.

V. STAFF APPROVALS

VI. PUBLIC FORUM

VII. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS

1. 11-8-8

897 South Third Street

Jason Bainum (Applicant) Mike Ferris (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs of the building and renderings of the proposed signs. Applicant has consulted with staff.

Install Signs

• Apply one sign on the window of the main entry door.

2. 11-8-9

559 South Sixth Street

Dan Bennett (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and contractor estimate detailing the proposed scope of work. Staff met with the owner onsite to assess the window conditions.

Replace Windows

• Remove seven (7) deteriorated window sashes on the east, south, and west sides of the house.

• Replace with new Jeld-wen, one-over-one, wood sash packs and new jam liners.

NEW APPLICATIONS

3. 11-8-10

804 Jaeger Street

Russell E. Blanks (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and a site plan.

Relocate Air-conditioner Unit

• Relocate air-conditioner unit from rear yard to front yard next to front porch, as shown on submitted site plan.

• Air-conditioner to be screened with vegetation.

4. 11-8-11

711 South Grant Avenue

Ellen Hinton (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a landscape plan, photographs, a survey, fence details.

Landscaping

• Remove overgrown vegetation and debris from narrow planting strip on east side of house.

• Bury downspout drains and regrade soil to allow proper runoff.

• Install low row of “Delaware Buff Cut Drywall” pavers as edging.

• Install brick paver walkway leading to entrance.

• Add new plantings, per submitted landscape plan.

Add Fence

• Install three foot high (3’h) wrought iron fencing at the edge of planting strip, per submitted landscape plan and fence detail.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30PM

5. 11-8-12

870 South Fifth Street

Amy Bonomi (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a roof assessment.

Replace Slate Roof

• Remove all slate roofing on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner

from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red”

or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

Repair Stop Gutters

• Examine all stop gutters on the main roof and make any repairs and/or replace the existing stop gutter system

on all elevations with new materials of appropriate dimension and profile.

• Reline with new copper, terne metal, galvanized metal, or E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes.

• Install new, round, galvanized metal downspouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.

6. 11-8-13

224 Reinhard Avenue

Klaus Gauer (Applicant) John A. Struzzi & Juris A. Kakis (Owner)

An application has been submitted with a drawing and photographs.

Replace Front Doors

• Remove existing fifteen (15) panel contemporary looking front doors.

• Replace with two (2), four (4) panel wood doors, per submitted

• New doors shall be painted to match existing.

Replace Windows

• Remove two (2) existing contemporary fixed windows.

• Reduce opening size and replace with two (2), 1-over-1, double hung, wood windows.

• Add wood, lap siding to match existing to fill in existing opening.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:00PM

7. 11-8-14

328 Jackson Street

Mark Longaberger (Applicant) Brian Anaya & Jennifer North (Owner)

An application has been submitted with a landscape plan and photographs.

Landscaping

• Add new planting in rear yard, per submitted landscape plan.

• Add 100 sq. ft. to existing patio in rear yard, using new bricks to match existing and set in matching herringbone pattern.

• Add new cobblestone walk to garage from rear patio to garage.

• Install new twelve by twelve (12’ x 12’) wood pergola to patio area, stained to match house trim.

8. 11-8-15

1120 South Pearl Street

Ryan Lauber (Applicant) Kara Miller (Owner)

An application has been submitted with a landscape plan and photographs.

Landscaping

• Install new irrigation system for lawn and flower beds.

• Add new plantings, per submitted landscape plan.

• Replace existing wood steps in rear (east) with new black-painted steel I-beam and brick steps.

• Install matching black steel I-beam and brick steps to side (south) entrance.

• Reshape walkway around house.

• Extend patio in rear with additional pavers to match existing: “Belcrest 700” brick pavers, laid in herringbone pattern.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:15PM

9. 11-8-17

685 City Park Avenue

John Behal, Behal Sampson Dietz (Applicant Brooke Bodney (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and site plans. Applicant has consulted with staff.

Replace Fence

• Replace wood fencing along north and south sides of the rear yard with brick wall, to match existing wall along west side.

• Add opening in existing brick wall to allow access to four feet of lot on west side of the wall.

10. 11-8-16

Rights-of-way in various locations throughout the District

Columbus Public Health (Applicant) City of Columbus (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, renderings, addresses, and sign material samples.

Install Signs

• Install twenty-eight (28) informational signs on existing sign in locations shown on pocket map submitted.

• Signs to be thirty inch by eighteen inch (30” x 18”), metal signs, per submitted drawing.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:30PM

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW

11. 11-8-18

213 East Beck Street

William Hugus Architects (Applicant) Jeff smith & Vijaya Iyer (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and plans.

Replace Rear Addition

• Remove non-original, one story, rear addition.

• Build new frame one story addition.

• Zoning variances will be required.

12. 11-8-19

697 South Third Street

William Hugus Architects (Applicant) Steve Shellebarger (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and plans.

New Garage

• Construct new two car frame garage, per submitted plans.

13. 11-8-20

563 South Grant Avenue

William Hugus Architects (Applicant) Kim McCormick (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and plans.

Second Story Addition

• Construct new second floor addition over existing frame lean-to, on rear of 1½ story cottage.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 11-8-1

116 Reinhard Avenue

Patricia A. Cunningham (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-8-1, 116 Reinhard Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove 195 square feet of damaged and deteriorated, concrete public sidewalk, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new brick sidewalk in the exact same location and of the exact same dimensions. Brick to be Belcrest 760, or similar, set in gravel/sand and laid in a common bond, to match adjacent brick sidewalk.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

• 11-8-2

568 South Sixth Street

Heather Densmore & Matt Sanders (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-8-2, 568 South Sixth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair/Replace Wood Siding

• Repair/replace all wood siding and trim as needed to match existing, in-kind, like-for-like.

• Inspect and replace any rotted underlying material, including wood columns, as needed.

• Prepare all wood siding and trim surfaces using the appropriate hand tools.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish coat all exterior wooden surfaces with exterior paint according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish color match existing or a paint schedule to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for review and final approval in consultation with the German Village Commission.

• 11-8-3

560 South Grant Avenue

Arrow Roofing & Siding (Applicant) Olivia & John Hanning (Owner)

Approve Application #11-8-3, 560 South Grant Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair/Replace Wood Siding

• Repair/replace deteriorated wood siding and trim, as needed, to match existing. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; in-kind, like-for-like, according to industry standards.

Exterior Painting

• Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary.

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish coat all exterior wooden surfaces with exterior paint according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish color schedule to be as submitted: Valspar “Courtyard Tan” (7002-13) for the body, and Valspar “Cincinnatian Hotel Hannaford” (3007-10C) for the trim.

• 11-8-4

115 East Redbud Alley

Mark Ours (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-8-4, 115 East Redbud Alley, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair/Replace Wood Siding

• Repair/replace all wood board and batten siding and wood trim, as needed, to match existing, in-kind, like-for-like.

• Prepare all wood siding and trim surfaces using the appropriate hand tools.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish coat all exterior wooden surfaces with exterior paint according to manufacturer’s specifications; finish color schedule to match existing.

• 11-8-5

865 City Park Avenue

Katharine Kerrigan (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-8-5, 865 City Park Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat color schedule to be as submitted: Behr “Intellectual” (US260-2) for the body, “Cotton Knit” (UL170-13) for the trim and “”High Drama” (UL100-5) for the front door.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-8-6

32-34 East Whittier Street

All Home Roofing & Siding, LLC (Applicant) William F. Plank (Owner)

Approve Application #11-8-6, 32-34 East Whittier Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be from the approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-8-7

539 Mohawk Street

Jon Buskirk, The JBV Group (Applicant) Stephen VanHorn (Owner)

Approve Application #11-8-7, 539 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Existing Fence with New Fence

• Install a new, six foot high (6′ H), wooden fence in the rear yard in the same location as the existing wood fence. Style of the new wood fence is to be selected from one (1) of the following appropriate options: a) Board-on-board, six foot high (6′ H), wood fence-finished side out facing the neighboring properties (i. e. all stringers and posts placed on the inside); b) Board-on-board, six foot high (6′ H), dog-eared wood fence with vertical 1″ x 6″ boards placed on both sides of the stringers; or c) Board-on-board, six foot high (6′ H), wood fence with all vertical boards installed with a top and bottom rail cap placed between the 4″ x 4″ wood posts.

• Prime and paint new fencing according to manufacturers specifications; finish coat to match trim color on house [dark gray].

Replace Garage Doors

• Replace deteriorated garage doors with new, custom-built, wood garage doors to match existing, like for like.

• New doors to be constructed of vertical tongue and groove wood with strap hinges, to fit exactly in the existing opening, but with the length shortened by three quarters of an inch (¾”), and a rubber door sweep attached to the interior bottom edge of the doors.

• Prime and paint all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications; finish coat to match existing.

VIII. OLD BUSINESS

IX. NEW BUSINESS

X. ADJOURNMENT

Commission Agenda 07/12/11

jgraichen — Wed, 06 Jul 2011 01:16:52 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

July 12, 2011

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, July 26, 2011.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, August 2, 2011.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, May 3, 2011.

V. STAFF APPROVALS

VI. PUBLIC FORUM

VII. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

STAFF RECOMMENDATION

1. 11-7-9b

145 East Sycamore Street

Norman Gruener (Applicant/Owner)

The applicant has submitted an application with photos and paint chips.

Exterior Masonry Painting

• Repaint brick house that has been painted. Color to be “Woodlawn Colonial Gray” (6004-1B).

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

Slate Roof Repair/Replacement

• Remove all deteriorated slate roofing on the main roof, rear (south) facing slope on the house, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Repair all deteriorated slate roofing on the front (north) facing roof slope using existing and salvaged slate shingles.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on existing chimney.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles on south facing roof. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

NEW APPLICATIONS

2. 11-7-18

711 Mohawk Street

Klaus Gauer (Applicant) Jerry & Jennifer Guy (Owner)

An application has been submitted with a photograph and drawing.

Replace Fencing

• Remove existing six foot (6’) high wood board privacy fence and gate.

• Replace with five foot (5’) high wrought iron fence with twelve inch (12”) solid brick wall as the base, per submitted drawing. New wrought iron gate to have six foot (6’) high, limestone-capped, brick piers on both sides.

3. 11-7-17

717 South Sixth Street

Ryan Lauber (Applicant) Heather Ward & Michael Smith (Owner)

An application has been submitted with a landscape plan and photographs.

Landscaping

• Install new patio in rear yard, to be constructed of natural bluestone.

• Install new walkway leading from patio to garage, to be constructed of “Ottawa Buff Rustic” limestone.

• Install built-in gas grill on patio.

• Install eight foot by twelve foot (8’ x 12’) wading pool with thirty-six inch (36”) tall waterfall in rear yard.

• Add new landscape lighting in rear yard.

• Add new plantings in front yard.

• All landscaping to be completed per submitted landscape plan.

Replace Fence

• Remove existing chain link fence in rear yard.

• Install a new, six foot (6’) high, wooden privacy fence on north and south sides of property, per submitted site plan. Fence to be board-on-board, six foot (6’) high wood fence, finished side out facing the neighboring properties (i.e. all stringers and posts placed on the inside); fence to be painted a dark green color.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30PM

4. 11-7-21

833 South Third Street

Brian Zingelmann (Applicant) Pat Smith (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, plans, elevations and window specifications.

Install Box Window

• Construct a new projecting box window on the rear (west) side of the house, per submitted plans and specifications.

• Box window to project three feet (3’) from existing wall, measure seven foot ten inches (7’ 10”) in width, and will be inset twelve inches (12”) from corner of the house.

• Roof shingles, siding, gutters and paint colors to match existing on the house.

• New windows to be two-over-two, SDL wood windows.

5. 11-7-22

771 South Sixth Street

Shawn McNeil (Applicant) Jean Hyde (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, a site plan, building plans and elevations.

Demolish Garage

• Demolish deteriorated frame garage.

Construct Garage

• Construct new twenty-two foot by twenty-two foot (22’ x 22’) frame garage per submitted plans and specifications.

• Roofing to be GAF 3-tab asphalt shingles, slate color, with gray metal ridge roll.

• Two single garage doors to be wood flush panel doors.

• Siding to be Hardie plank six inch (6”) smooth lap siding, with smooth trim, fascia and wood soffits; paint colors to be Sherwin Williams “Favorite Tan” (SW 6157) for the body and white for the trim.

6. 11-7-28

780 Jaeger Street

William Hermanson (Applicant) Brent Goode (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs and window specifications. Staff has conducted a site visit to assess the existing window condition.

Window Replacement

• Replace existing one-over-one wood windows with new Jeld-wen one-over-one wood windows.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:00PM

7. 11-7-20

689 South Third Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Jon Knitter (Owner)

An application has been submitted with site plan, building plans, elevations and photographs.

Demolish Garage

• Remove severely deteriorated 385 s.f. frame garage in rear of property.

Construct New Garage

• Build new 484 s.f. frame garage in roughly the same location, per submitted plans.

• New garage to be twenty-two feet by twenty-two feet (22’ x 22’) with a flat, rubber membrane roof, wood lap siding, two (2) wood, single car, garage doors on the south side and one wood service door on the east side.

• Install new concrete apron on the south side of the garage.

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW

8. 11-7-23

792 South Fifth Street

William Hugus Architects (Applicant) James Fleming (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, plans and elevations.

New Garage Construction

• Construct a new twenty foot by twenty four foot four inch (20’ x 24’ 4”) frame garage with home office space in rear yard.

• Variances likely for use, lot coverage, and rear yard (possible), to be determined.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:15PM

9. 11-7-24

20 Stewart Avenue (Stewart Elementary School) and 966 South High Street (Maennerchor Building)

Hardlines Design Company (Applicant) Columbus City Schools (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, existing site plan and Sanborn maps.

Demolition

• Demolish Maennerchor Building.

Rehabilitation of School

• Rehabilitation of Stewart Elementary School to include a 16,500 square foot addition, and new landscaping.

Street Closure

• Closure and redirection of a portion of Pearl Street to accommodate addition to school.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:45PM

STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS

10. 11-7-19

644 Pearl Street

Mindy Coffey (Applicant) Mark Coffey (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs, drawings, a rendering and a site plan.

Install Awning

• Install new fabric awning over store front, per submitted rendering and specifications.

• Awning to be fourteen feet, ten inches (14’ 10”) long; shed style with three foot (3’) projection; open sides; six inch (6”) straight valance; color to be dark gray with the business name and logo; frame to be black, welded aluminum.

Install Sign

• Install new two foot by three foot (2’ x 3’) painted aluminum hanging sign on existing sign frame above the entrance.

Install Gate

• Install new six foot (6’) high wrought iron gate on south side of building, per submitted drawing.

11. 11-7-25

100 Thurman Avenue

Jamie Weilbacher (Applicant) Jon & Abigail Sammons (Owner)

An application has been submitted with photographs.

Replace Slate Roof

• Remove all deteriorated slate roofing on the upper roof of the house, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

12. 11-7-26

136 East Whittier Street

Juanita Furuta (Applicant/Owner)

An application has been submitted with a roof assessment and photographs.

Remove Slate Roof

• Remove deteriorated slate shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

Replace with asphalt shingle roofing

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] CertainTeed Carriage House (dimensional) [ ] Stonegate Gray

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

13. 11-7-27

638 Lazelle Street

Corinne Warrener (Applicant) Joy & Tony Stickel (Owner)

An application has been submitted with a roof plan and photograph.

• Install new satellite dish on roof of apartment building, per submitted plans and specifications.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 11-7-1

753 Mohawk Street

Dehlco Construction Services, LLC (Applicant) Chad Irving (Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-1, 753 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install Paver Patio

• Install new Belcrest 760A brick paver patio in rear yard, per submitted site plan.

• Patio to cover an area thirteen feet, six inches by eleven feet, six inches (13’6” x 11’6”) with a six foot (6’) diameter mulch bed in the center, around the existing Japanese Maple tree.

• Pavers are to be laid in a running bond pattern.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• 11-7-2

644 South Pearl Street

Mindy Coffey (Applicant) Mark & Mindy Coffey (Owners)

Approve Application #11-7-2, 644 South Pearl Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Repair/replace existing concrete sidewalks and apron as needed to match existing.

• Install french drain from gutter per industry standards.

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, concrete public and service sidewalks, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

Install French Drain

• 11-7-3

1000 City Park Avenue

Columbus Recreation & Parks Department (Applicant/Owners)

Approve Application #11-7-3, 1000 City Park Drive, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair/Replace Downspouts

• Examine all existing gutters and downspouts on the house and make any repairs and/or replace the existing gutter system on all elevations with new galvanized half round gutters painted to look like copper.

• Install new, round metal downspouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.

Recaulk Windows

• Remove all deteriorated sealant that has failed around 10 of the windows.

• Install new backer rods, primer and new urethane sealant around these windows.

• New sealant shall be painted, after fully cured in accordance with manufacturer’s specifications; color to match existing color of window trim.

• 11-7-4

783 Mohawk Street

Sarah S. Walker & Kelly E. Walker (Applicant/Owner)

Approve application #11-7-4, 783 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Sidewalk

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated concrete sidewalk along north side of the house, as indicated on submitted site plan; dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

Replace Fence

• Remove deteriorated wood privacy fencing in rear yard, as shown on submitted site plan.

• Install new 6’ high wood board privacy fence to match existing in dimensions and location. Fence shall be painted or stained with an opaque stain in accordance with manufacturer’s specifications; color chips showing the finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application.

• 11-7-5

225 Lear Street

Kim & Eric Zipfel (Applicant/Owner)

Approve application #11-7-5, 225 Lear Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair/Replace Box Gutters

• Examine all box gutters on the house and make any repairs and/or replace the existing box gutter system on all elevations with new materials of appropriate dimension and profile.

• Reline with new copper, terne metal, galvanized metal, or E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes.

• Install new, round, galvanized metal downspouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior siding and wooden surfaces on the house using the appropriate hand tools.

• Repair/replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wooden trim with new wood of exact same profile and dimension as the original.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat all exterior surfaces with exterior paint according to manufacturer’s specifications per submitted color schedule: Behr Exterior Paint, “Quail Ridge” (ECC-18-1) for the siding and fence, “Pebble Shore” (ECC-18-2) for the trim, and “Red Hawk” (ECC-46-3) or “Night Tide” (ECC-30-3) for the front door.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-7-6

37 East Kossuth Street

Dehlco Construction Services, LLC (Applicant) Robert & Amy Borman (Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-6, 37 East Kossuth, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Masonite Siding

• Replace all Masonite siding; repair/replace all wood trim as needed to match existing, in-kind, like-for-like.

• Install with new “Cove 106” style wood siding in accordance with manufacturer’s specifications and industry standards.

• Prepare all wood siding and trim surfaces using the appropriate hand tools.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces on all sides with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish coat all exterior wooden surfaces with exterior paint according to manufacturer’s specifications; color schedule to match existing.

• 11-7-7

193-199 Berger Alley

Juliet Bullock (Applicant) E-Alvarez, LP (Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-7, 193-199 Berger Alley, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA#08-2-10c, 193-199 Berger Alley, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Expired: 2-14-09.

08-2-10c

193-199 Berger Alley

• Tree removal from the rear yard.

• Replace aluminum storm windows and doors with sugar creek storm windows/ doors.

• Repair/ Replace half round gutters to match the existing gutters, like-for-like.

• Repair the deteriorated concrete stoop.

• Modified windows on the house facing Berger Alley will be replaced with matching custom made windows.

• Replace the second story rear door as per the submitted cut sheets.

Commission directed the HPO staff to convert the application to a staff approval

• 11-7-8

578 South Fifth Street

Jamie Weilbacher (Applicant) Brian Santin (Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-8, 578 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the garage roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

Exterior Painting

• Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Paint to match existing color scheme. Any new colors are to be submitted with paint color chips to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• 11-7-9a

145 East Sycamore Street

Norman Gruener (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-9a, 145 East Sycamore Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove Shutters

• Remove deteriorated, non-original, non-contributing shutters from the front of the house.

Spot Tuck Point

• Check all mortar joints on exposed brick wall for soundness. All sound mortar to remain in place.

• Replace any/all missing damaged material, as needed, and replace with new or used brick of the exact same shape, dimension, and color; like-for-like. Paint to match existing wall color.

• Use hand tools to remove any/all loose mortar to a depth of 3/4″.

• Moisten surface with water, and spot point mortar joints and all drill holes as needed with mortar of matching color, texture, hardness, and joint profile.

• New mortar must be softer than the masonry, and no harder than the historic mortar, to allow for expansion and contraction of the masonry. Original mortar mix was composed of 1 part lime to 2 parts sand. White portland cement may be substituted for up to (but no more than) 20 percent of the lime content. (The owner is advised to use the approved 12 parts sand-4 parts lime-1 part white portland cement formula approved by the National Trust For Historic Preservation. Please refer to Preservation Brief 2- “Repointing Mortar in Historic Brick Buildings”, available at http://www.cr.nps.gov/hps/tps/briefs/brief02.htm).

Landscaping

• Remove existing bushes in the front yard.

• Replace with new low and medium boxwood and perennials, per submitted landscape plan.

Replace Gate

• Replace wood gate on side entrance with new wood, board gate to match existing in dimension and detail.

• Gate to be painted or stained within one (1) year. Stain/paint color to match existing or new color to be submitted to the Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

Power Wash House

• Clean all unpainted masonry in accordance with industry standards and Columbus City Codes. Pressure is not to exceed 300 lb./p.s.i. and utilizing a broad fan tip. Should chemical cleaning be proposed by the owner or contractor or be determined to be necessary by Historic Preservation Office staff for paint removal of Previously Painted Masonry: the following procedure is required: Using the most diluted solution possible, perform a patch test by chemically cleaning a two foot by two foot (2′ x2′) section in the least visible location possible. Following the application of the approved cleaning solution, the entire area which has been treated is to be rinsed with water in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations. If air pressure is needed for either the cleaning or the rinsing procedures, only a broad fan tip is to be used and the pressure is not to exceed 300 lb/psi. (Refer to Preservation Brief 1- “The Cleaning and Waterproof Coating of Masonry Buildings”).

Repair Exterior Door

• Make any/all necessary repairs to the existing, contributing, wooden door on front entrance, per industry standards.

• Paint door in accordance with manufacturer’s specifications; finish coat color to be “Knight’s Armor” (D58-5).

Install New Half-Round Gutters

• Remove the existing, deteriorated half round gutters and down spouts and dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all deteriorated and damaged wood trim and fascia with new wood of same dimension as necessary. Replace all metal flashing as necessary.

• Prime and finish coat all wood trim and fascia prior to the installation of all new gutters and down spouts; finish paint color on trim to be Lowe’s “Woodlawn Bedroom White” (6004-1A).

• Install new, 5″, half-round metal gutters and new round, metal down spouts of the appropriate dimension. Finish color to match the existing trim color.

• Make any/all necessary repairs to the existing storm sewer tile system to assure proper drainage away from the foundations of this and neighboring properties. If deemed necessary, install a French drain system or similar, appropriate drainage system in accordance with all applicable City Building Codes and industry standards.

Replace Lighting

• Replace exterior wall mounted light fixtures with new wall mounted light fixtures in same locations as existing fixtures. One fixture to be installed above front door and the second fixture to be installed to the right of the side door.

• Detailed specifications for the light fixtures are to be submitted to the Historic Preservation Office prior to installation.

Install Shutters

• Install exterior, wooden, louvered shutters on first floor front windows and door.

• Shutters are to be appropriately sized for the openings they surround.

• Prime shutters on all sides and paint in accordance with manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat to be “Knight’s Armor” (D58-5) color to match the front door.

Install New Storm Door

• Install a new, full view, white aluminum storm door on the front entrance, per submitted cut sheet.

• 11-7-10

857 Mohawk Street

Todd Freeman (Applicant) Janice Roth (Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-10, 857 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove Existing Curb Section and Install New

• Remove the existing, deteriorated concrete curb section and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install sandstone curb from the city curb bank to match adjacent historic curbs with the exact same size and dimension and in accordance with all applicable Columbus City Building Codes and industry standards; like-for-like.

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, concrete sidewalk, in the area indicated on submitted site plan, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new brick sidewalk in the same location using appropriate paver bricks to match existing adjacent brick sidewalk in dimension and color; new walk to be laid in a running bond.

• Remove existing section of brick sidewalk adjacent to front steps and relay in a running bond pattern using as many existing bricks as possible.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

• 11-7-11

540 South Sixth Street

Karla Kaeser (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-11, 540 South Sixth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install Gutter Screens

• Install new aluminum hinge gutter screens on existing 5” half round gutter system on entire house; installation to be completed in accordance with manufacturer’s specifications.

• 11-7-12

49 East Sycamore Street

Thomas D. Evans (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-12, 49 East Sycamore Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood elements on the porch, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the porch for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color schedule to match existing.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-7-13

306 East Beck Street

Stephanie A. Connor (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-13, 306 East Beck Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood elements on the main house, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.

• Prepare all exterior surfaces on the house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat color schedule to be: Olympic Paints “Autumn Gray” (D68-5) for the body; “Bone White” (D20-3) for the trim; and Sherwin Williams “Bolero” (SW 7600) for the shutters, doors and garage doors.

• Any previously unpainted masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-7-14

37 East Deshler Avenue

Charles & Carol Mix (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-14, 37 East Deshler Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install New Doors

• Install new wood door in existing door jambs on side entrances. New door to be a four-panel door or half-lite wood door, as shown in submitted drawings.

• Set on 1 1/2 pair 3 1/2″ x 3 1/2″ butt hinges; hinge locations to be determined by the existing jamb.

• Door to be stained to match front door (natural oak); finish all six sides.

Install New Storm Door

• Install a new aluminum, three-quarter lite storm door on side entrance to match existing storm door on rear.

• If other than “white”, color chip for the new storm door to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to installation of the door.

• 11-7-15

615 South Lazelle Street

Bill Davis/Mr. Fix-it (Applicant) Alan Paul (Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-15, 615 South Lazelle Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA#08-2-9, 615 South Lazelle Street, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Expired: 2-5-09.

Approve Application #08-2-9, 615 South Lazelle Street with the following stipulations:

• Replace the non original and non contributing 19 windows on the property with all wood windows (inside and outside) as per the submitted cut sheets.

• Storm windows shall not be installed over the replacement windows.

• Replacement windows will fit the openings exactly; window openings shall not be downsized.

• Obscure glass will be installed in the restroom window on the side elevation; all other windows to have clear glass.

Motion: Colvin/ Panzer (6-0-0) APPROVED

• 11-7-16

801 South Sixth Street

Schmidt’s Restaurant and Sausage Haus (Applicant) J. Fred Schmidt Packing Company (Owner)

Approve Application #11-7-16, 801 South Sixth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Sidewalk

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, brick sidewalk, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Replace with damaged brick with new Belcrest brick and relay sidewalk in the exact same location and with the same herringbone pattern.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

VIII. OLD BUSINESS

IX. NEW BUSINESS

X. ADJOURNMENT

06/07/11 Commission Agenda

jgraichen — Mon, 06 Jun 2011 02:55:40 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

June 7, 2011

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, June 28, 2011.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, July 12, 2011.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, May 3, 2011.

V. PUBLIC FORUM

VI. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

CONTINUED APPLICATIONS

1. 11-4-18

943-945 City Park Avenue

Phil Barger (Owner)

An application, cutsheet, and photographs have been submitted.

• Remove deteriorated hinged garage doors.

• Install 8’ x 7’ flush wood overhead doors.

• Remove existing asphalt shingles above garage doors and install new 1’ x 6’ cedar siding; to be painted “Keystone Gray”.

NEW APPLICATIONS

2. 11-6-11

751 Jaeger Street

Klaus Gauer (Applicant) Jeanne M. Liking (Owner)

An application, product brochure, material sample, and photographs have been submitted.

• Remove deteriorated wood tongue-and-groove porch floor.

• Install new Aeratis “Traditions” PVC porch flooring.

3. 11-6-12

213 East Beck Street

Klaus J. Gauer (Applicant) Vijaya Iyer & Jeffrey A. Smith (Owners)

An application, product information, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Install New Windows

• Remove twelve (12) non-original, double-hung window sashes.

• Install twelve (12) new Lincoln sash pack replacement windows.

Rebuild Retaining Wall

• Rebuild and modify the existing brick retaining wall along the west elevation (Fifth Street), per the submitted drawing.

• Remove a portion of the brick wall and insert iron fencing to accommodate existing tree.

4. 11-6-13

325 East Livingston Avenue

Danite Sign Co. (Applicant) JMM Real Estate, LLC (Owner)

An application, drawing, and photographic rendering have been submitted.

• Install 2’ x 9’ non-illuminate wall sign.

• Sing to be aluminum with vinyl graphics.

5. 11-6-14

310-312 Beck Street

Jon Buskirk/the JVB Group (Applicant) Guy Rub Adi Mizrahi (Owner)

An application, product information, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Egress Conversion of Dormer Window–South

• Remove the existing, contributing, wood, double-hung window sashes from third floor dormer on south elevation only.

• Make any/all necessary jamb repairs in accordance with industry standards and applicable Columbus Building codes.

• Recondition the existing, contributing, wood, one-over-one sashes to function as a casement window unit – hinged on the inside to swing into the third floor living space. The double-hung meeting rails to retain the offset joinery.

• Reconditioned wood casement window unit to retain the appearance of the historic, wooden, double-hung windows and function as one (1), in-swinging casement window unit to allow for necessary emergency egress in accordance with all applicable City Building Codes.

• Prime and paint exterior windows and trim to match existing exterior paint color(s) like-for-like.

Install New Roof Windows

• Install two (2) new roof windows on the east roof slope and two (2) new roof windows on the west roof slope to allow light and ventilation to the finished third floor space.

• Request placement in upper one-third of each roof slope.

6. 11-6-15

621 South Grant Street

Donley Builders (Applicant) Beck Place, LLC (Owner)

An application, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

A code violation has been issued for work done prior to approval.

• Construct 5’ wood privacy fence on second floor terrace.

• Fence is similar to other fences located on the property.

7. 11-6-16

124 East Beck Street

Brett & Dawna Peters (Applicants/Owners)

An application, product information, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Install New Brick Patio

• Install new patio in rear yard using reclaimed brick.

• Patio to have sculpted boarder to allow for landscape plantings.

Install New Outdoor Fireplace

• New fireplace to be stone and copper, per the submitted drawing.

• All work to be completed on interior of existing privacy fence.

8. 11-6-17

693 City Park Avenue

Gary J. Alexander, Architect (Applicant) Mr. & Mrs. Ron Hagan (Owners)

An Application, siteplan, drawings, Sanborn mapping, and photographs have been submitted.

Variances have previously been approved for the proposed project.

• Enlarge existing carport.

• Remodel existing kitchen.

• Replace existing three-season room.

9. 11-6-18

994 Jaeger Street

Carlos Alvarez & Zsuzsanna E. Tomay-ybly (Applicant/Owner)

An application, work specification, site plan, photographs, and drawings have been submitted.

Sub-Surface Piping

• Remove all sub-surface perforated piping (connecting to downspouts of roofs) that is currently installed around both house and carriage house, and connecting both to Jaeger Street drainage

• Replace all sub-surface piping, connecting to downspouts and draining to Jaeger Street drainage.

Plant Material

• Remove all plant material on site, except front yard Serviceberry Tree, rear yard Japanese Maple, and all Boxwood shrubs (note: list of plant existing plant materials to be removed are listed on the Conceptual Review submittal)

• Replace the following new plant materials (as shown on plan): (4) Hinoke Cypress; (19) Upright European Hornbeam ‘Franz Fontaine’ trees (3” caliper, 14-16’ tall x 42” wide foliage); (50) Boxwood shrubs; 58 linear feet Taxus hedges; Liriope Groundcover; Vinca Groundcover

Regrading

• Regrade all surfaces to re-establish a positive flow of surface water away from buildings (see attached drainage sketches)

Paving

• Remove all existing brick and bluestone paving surfaces & limestone steps (except original limestone steps to remain & be reset at proper elevation)

• Replace all paving surfaces with, in front & south side, Sheffield sandstone (seen at 157 E. Deshler) paving and, in front, add brick path to original stone steps; paving and steps in rear yard, Lithocrete concrete paving (color 920 Slate); Steps and cheek walls in front to be Indiana Sandstone (see attached detail)- note that due to the lack of gutter downspouts on the little roof above the front door water currently runs off of the two sides of this roof and onto the ground so the ‘stoop’ area is narrow next to the door to allow water to fall on the ground instead of the stoop. Therefore, to make the stoop appear ‘more horizontal and streamlined’, low contemporary cheek walls are located further out from the house

Drainage

• Add in rear yard, 9” wide x 24” minimum deep stone ‘dry-wells’ along paving edges that paving slopes to, to collect rain water from paving; paving in the rear yard (or sides) will not be connected to the storm sewer system

Fencing

• Front iron fence – Reuse and Add (see attached detail) – Add brick curb, at front yard, (to match brick & mortar on house) with 2 ½” thick Indiana Sandstone cap & cut bottom of fence to match height of existing (& neighbors) fences

• Wood fence & gates – Replace (see attached photo) – Replace existing wood fence (& gates) with 6’ high wood fence as shown on plan (& gates) on top of 2-3” high x 6” wide concrete curb (smooth trowel finish) – also to retain soil where elevations on each side of fence are difference; fence to be Benjamin Moore Dark Olive #2140-30; boards to be 6” wide “V” groove boards with ship lap joints

• North side – Add 1”-2” high, smooth-troweled concrete band along property line at depth to protect foundation of house from future intruding tree roots

Front Sidwalk/Street Curb

• Replace existing concrete sidewalk with new concrete sidewalk; replace stone curb, as needed, from City of Columbus “Curb Bank”

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW APPLICATIONS

10. 11-6-19

156 East Thurman Avenue

Cheryl Subler & Joe Turbett (Owners)

An application, siteplan, and photographs have been submitted.

Conceptual Review

• Proposed demolition of existing two-car garage built in 1970.

• Proposed construction of two-story, two-car garage.

11. 11-6-20

797 South Sixth Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Erin Crotty & Craig Kent (Owners)

An application, siteplan, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

This project has previously received a conceptual review.

Conceptual Review

• Proposed construction of a two-story rear addition on existing 2 ½ -story residence (see packet for details).

12. 11-6-21

792 South Fifth Street

Klaus Gauer (Applicant) Jim Fleming (Owner)

An application and photographs have been submitted.

Conceptual Review

• Discuss possibility of constructing a gabled-roof two-car garage with office space above.

• A flat-roof 2-car garage has been previously approved (COA# 10-3-11).

STAFF RECOMMENDED APPLICATIONS

13. 11-6-22

858 South Fifth Street

Richard Zapor (Applicant) Barbara & Patrick Bowers (Owners)

An application and photograph has been submitted.

• Install custom fixed-panel aluminum storm windows (nine windows total).

• New storms to be clear double-strength 1/8” thick glass enclosed in aluminum extrusion with weather-stripping; installed directly to blind stop and held in place by ¾” shoe mold.

• New storms will be painted to match to match the existing color of the rehabbed windows.

14. 10-12-24B

143 East Whittier Street

Michele Lavon (Owner)

A revised drawing and photographs have been submitted.

• Alteration of rear/south elevation of previously approved rear addition (see packet for details).

15. 11-6-23

248 East Whittier Street

Amanda Gallo (Owner)

An application, paint chip, and photographs have been submitted.

• Remove existing aluminum siding and repair existing cedar shake siding underneath as needed.

• Restore cedar shake siding to be painted Benjamin Moore “Gunmetal” (1602).

16. 11-6-24

144 East Whittier Street

Joyce Politi (Applicant/Owner)

An application, product information, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Window Replacement

• Remove twenty-two (22) existing, non-original, wood, one-over-one sashes, awning basement sashes, and multi-light attic windows.

• Install new, wood, Empire sashes to match existing.

17. 11-6-25

533 South Fifth Street

Indicia Investments, LLC (Applicant/Owner)

An application for exterior painting and reroofing has been submitted with photographs. A similar color scheme was previously approved in 2003. A light color for the brick had also been approved by the Commission in 1982 and 1970, and was in place at that time. The applicant has been asked to submit paint chips.

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color to match existing.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

Reroof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] CertainTeed Carriage House (dimensional) [ ] Stonegate Gray

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] GAF Royal Sovereign (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

[ ] Celotex (standard 3-tab) [ ] Heritage Gray

[ ] Slate Gray

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

[ ] Tamko (standard 3-tab) [ ] Antique Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 11-6-1

303 East Livingston Avenue

David Jameson (Applicant)/ Jeffery H. Jordan (Owner)

Approve Application #09-11-21, 303 E. Livingston Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA#09-11-21, 303 E. Livingston Avenue, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Expired: 11-2-10.

Approve Application #09-11-21, 303 East Livingston Avenue, as submitted with the following clarifications:

• Remove and replace rear exterior door with new wider (36”) steel entry door per submitted cutsheet.

• Construct new handicap accessible ramp.

• New door to be a half-lite metal door to match the existing material and is to be painted “blue” to match existing.

• Both sidelights are to be removed; one side to be finished with a 1x board painted to match the existing “blue”.

• New access ramp to have spilt-faced block above grade, without thin-brick, and with a pipe-rail. If the total height is 17” or lower a railing is not required.

• All final details to be submitted to HPO Staff for review and approval prior to issuance of certificate.

MOTION: Thiell/O’Donnell (4-0-0) APPROVED.

• 11-6-2

1066 Jaeger Street

Harry Skinner (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-2, 1066 Jaeger Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Spot Tuck Point

• Check all mortar joints on brick walls for soundness. All sound mortar to remain in place.

• Use hand tools to remove any/all loose or non-matching mortar to a depth of 3/4″.

• Moisten surface with water, and spot point as needed with mortar of matching color, texture, hardness, and joint profile. New mortar must be softer than the masonry, and no harder than the historic mortar, to allow for expansion and contraction of the masonry. Original mortar mix was composed of 1 part lime to 2 parts sand. White portland cement may be substituted for up to (but no more than) 20 percent of the lime content. (The owner is advised to use the approved 12 parts sand-4 parts lime-1 part white portland cement formula approved by the National Trust For Historic Preservation. Please refer to Preservation Brief 2- “Repointing Mortar in Historic Brick Buildings”, available at http://www.cr.nps.gov/hps/tps/briefs/brief02.htm).

Replace missing mortar in foundation

• Remove all non-original, and deteriorated mortar from stone foundation with the appropriate hand tools to a depth of no less than one inch (1″).

• Moisten surface with water and solid point with mortar of matching color, texture, hardness, and joint profile. New mortar must be softer than the masonry, and no harder than the historic mortar, to allow for expansion and contraction of the masonry. Original mortar mix was composed of 1 part lime to 2 parts sand. White portland cement may be substituted for up to (but no more than) 20 percent of the lime content. (The owner is advised to use the approved 12 parts sand-4 parts lime-1 part white portland cement formula approved by the National Trust For Historic Preservation. Please refer to Preservation Brief 2- “Repointing Mortar in Historic Brick Buildings” supplied by staff.)

Clean masonry

• Clean all unpainted brick and stone in accordance with industry standards and Columbus City Codes.

• Pressure is not to exceed 300 lb./p.s.i. and a broad fan tip is to be used.

• Should chemical cleaning be proposed by the owner or contractor the following patch test procedure is required: Using the most diluted solution possible, perform a patch test by chemically cleaning a two foot by two foot (2′ x2′) section in the least visible location possible. Patch test to be approved by Historic Preservation Office staff prior to proceeding with the complete job.

• Following the application of the approved cleaning solution, the entire area which has been treated is to be rinsed with water in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations.

• If air pressure is needed for either the cleaning or the rinsing procedures, only a broad fan tip is to be used and the pressure is not to exceed 300 lb/psi. (Refer to Preservation Brief 1- “The Cleaning and Waterproof Coating of Masonry Buildings”).

• 11-6-3

595 South Sixth Street

James Plunkett (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-3, 595 South Sixth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair box gutters

• Examine all box gutters on main roof and make any repairs and/or replace existing box gutter system on all elevations with new materials of appropriate dimension and profile. Reline with new copper, terne metal, galvanized metal, or E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes.

• Install new, round, galvanized metal down spouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.

Replace porch roof

• Remove any/all asphalt shingles or rolled roofing on the porch roof down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Examine all structural members of the flat roofing system from the square (i.e. top plate) to determine condition. Make any/all necessary structural repairs as needed in accordance with standard building practices and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.

• Replace any/all deteriorated and damaged wood fascia with new wood of same dimension as necessary. Prime and finish coat all wood fascia prior to the installation of all new gutter and down spouts; color to match the existing trim color. Paint color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff.

• 11-6-4

756 Jaeger Street

John Pribble, III (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-4, 756 Jaeger Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint colors to be: Main body = Sherwin Williams “Perfect Greige” SW 6073, Trim = Sherwin Williams “Heron Plume” SW6070, and Accent = Sherwin Williams “Spalding Gray” SW 6074.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-6-5

877 Mohawk Street

Cheryl Brown (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-5, 877 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the entryway of main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color to match existing, Olympic Paint “Fisherman’s Net” D11-2.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-6-6

789 City Park Avenue

Richard & Lynne Freeman (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-6, 789 City Park Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Replace Fence

• Remove deteriorated wood fencing around rear yard.

• Replace with new six foot (6’ h) wood fence in same location, with material, dimensions and design to match existing, per submitted site plan and photos.

• Fence shall be painted or stained within one (1) year; color chips are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint or stain.

• 11-6-7

557 South Fifth Street

Juanita Furuta (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-7, 557 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color to match existing: Sherwin Williams “Marooned” SW 6020 and Sherwin Williams

“Cyberspace” SW 7076.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-6-8

783 South Third Street

Jim O’Brien (Applicant) Robert Scheibeck (Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-8, 783 South Third Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Reroof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] Certain Teed (standard 3-tab) [ ] Nickel Gray

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-6-9

201 East Whittier Street

Casey James Covrett (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-9, 201 East Whittier Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install brick walkway

• Install thirty-two inch by twenty-four foot (32” x 24’) brick walkway in rear yard adjacent to garage, as shown on submitted site plan.

• Bricks shall be Holland “Autumn Blend” color and placed in a running bond pattern.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

Install wood gate

• Install six feet by three and a half feet (6’ h x 3.5’ w), flat top, wood gate at rear of property, per submitted plans and drawing.

• 11-6-10

650 South Grant Avenue

Richard and Connie Tressel (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-6-10, 650 South Grant Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair and repoint brick steps

• Remove any/all damaged material and replace with like-for-like materials, per industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Replacement brick pavers to match existing in size, color, and shape. New mortar shall match existing mortar in color, texture, hardness, and joint profile.

VII. OLD BUSINESS

VIII. NEW BUSINESS

IX. ADJOURNMENT

Commission Agenda 05/03/11

jgraichen — Thu, 28 Apr 2011 01:25:28 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

May 3, 2011

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, May 31, 2011.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, June 7, 2011.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, May 3, 2011.

V. PUBLIC FORUM

VI. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

CONTINUED APPLICATIONS

1. 11-4-18

943-945 City Park Avenue

Phil Barger (Owner)

An application, cutsheet, and photographs have been submitted.

• Remove deteriorated hinged garage doors.

• Install 8’ x 7’ flush wood overhead doors.

• Remove existing asphalt shingles above garage doors and install new 1’ x 6’ cedar siding; to be painted “Keystone Gray”.

The following is taken from the Unapproved April 5, 2011 German Village Commission Meeting Minutes:

Continue Application #11-4-18, 943-945 City Park Avenue, to allow the applicant time to submit additional information:

MOTION: Colvin/Case (6-0-0) CONTINUED.

Commissioner Comments

• The Commission approves of the concept of the proposed work; and referred the applicant to visit a garage located near Jackson and Lazelle streets.

• The applicant should submit a flat door with applied trim similar to the garage discussed, and should supply details for siding, trim, and roof interface for review at the next commission meeting.

• The siding underneath the asphalt should be investigated and photographed for historic evidence.

NEW APPLICATIONS

2. 11-5-24

544 South Fourth Street

Michael J. Rourke (Applicant/Owner)

An application, product information, and photographs have been submitted.

Apply Sealer to Brick House

• Clean loose materials from all brick surfaces.

• Apply clear, Stone Tech, X-1 Satin Sealer to exterior brick and mortar on front and side elevations of house.

• Application is by low pressure sprayer.

Repair Brick Sidewalk

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, brick public and service sidewalks, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new or used brick in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

3. 11-5-25

762 South Fifth Street

Patricia Hook (Applicant/Owner)

An application, product information, and photographs have been submitted. A staff site visit has been conducted.

Install New Windows

• Remove eight (8) existing three-over-one and later model one-over-one, wood, double-hung windows.

• Install new, wood, one-over-one, Lincoln Sash Pack replacement windows.

• Wood windows and trim to be painted Sherwin Williams color #7008 “Alabaster.”

4. 11-5-26

310-312 Beck Street

Jon Buskirk/the JVB Group (Applicant) Guy Rub Adi Mizrahi (Owner)

An application, product information, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Install New Skylights

• Install two (2) new Velux, manual-venting skylights on the east and west slopes of the roof.

• Placement to be approximately 11’ and 16’ from the front/south elevation and centered between the roof peak and soffit.

• Each skylight measures approximately 16’ x 46’.

Install Egress Windows

• Create emergency egress windows in dormer by altering the existing wood windows to swing inward.

• Window sashes will be pinned together and mortise hinges attached on the interior.

• A window pull and latch will be placed on the interior.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30 PM

5. 11-5-27

733 Jaeger Street

Brian Collins/bcf Design & Development, Ltd. (Applicant) Sharon & Richard Pettit (Owner)

An application, site plan, and drawings have been submitted.

Screened Porch Addition

• Construct a new 13’ x 13.5’ screened porch to rear (west elevation) of house, per submitted drawings.

• All wood trim to be painted.

• Infill siding and shingle to match existing.

6. 11-5-28

1066 Jaeger Street

Harry L. Skinner (Applicant/Owner)

An application, site plan, work specifications, and photographs have been submitted.

Construct New Screened Porch

• Existing deck to be expanded to 10’ x 16’.

• Construct new, 10’ x 16’ screened porch on top of the existing rear wood deck, per submitted work specifications.

• All paint, gutters, downspouts, and shingles to match existing colors on house.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:00 PM

7. 11-5-29

240 Reinhard Avenue

Blostein/Overly Architects (Applicant) Connie Cline& Louis Smith (Owner)

An application, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Enlarge Existing Kitchen

• Enlarge and reconfigure kitchen at rear/north, first level, per submitted drawings.

8. 11-5-30

219 East Beck Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Phil Fankhauser (Owner)

An application, work specifications, and drawings have been submitted.

Exterior Alterations/New Addition

• Construct new addition and make exterior alterations to existing structure per the submitted work specifications and drawings.

9. 11-5-31

994 Jaeger Street

Carlos Alvarez & Zsuzsanna E. Tomay-ybly (Applicant/Owner)

An application, work specification, site plan, photographs, and drawings have been submitted.

Landscaping

Install new landscaping per the submitted work specifications and drawings.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:30 PM

10. 11-5-32

399 East Livingston Avenue

Gary Sebach (Applicant) Education First Credit Union (Owner)

An application, work specification, photographs, and drawings have been submitted.

Exterior Alterations/New Additions

• Construct new entrance lobby per submitted drawings

• Remove portion of existing building on rear, and construct new covered, drive-thru teller area, per submitted drawings

• Install new parking at the new entrance

• Modify existing iron fence and piers to accommodate new entry drive and parking.

11. 11-5-33

210 Thurman Avenue

John Behal – Behal/Sampson/Dietz (Applicant) Rebecca Milnes (Owner)

An application, work specification, photographs, and drawings have been submitted.

Façade Renovation

• Complete façade renovation per the submitted work specifications and drawings.

12. 11-5-34

685 City Park Avenue

John Behal – Behal/Sampson/Dietz (Applicant) Brooke Bodney (Owner)

An application, photographs, and drawings have been submitted.

Construct New Addition

• Construct a new, two-story, wood-sided addition, per the submitted drawings.

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW

13. 11-5 –35

238 Lansing Street

Klaus Gauer (Applicant) / Brian Kelly & Jennifer Kehn (Owner)

An application, site plan, and photographs have been submitted.

New Garage Construction

• Demolish the existing frame shed in the rear of the property

• Construct a new 20’ x 20’, frame garage similar in design to adjacent property to the east (242 Lansing St)

STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS

14. 11-5-6a

1054 Pearl Street

Dehlco Construction Services (Applicant) Grand Canal Properties, LLC (Owner)

Application #11-5-6 has been divided into item ‘a’ for German Village Commission review under Staff Recommendations, and item ‘b’ for Staff Approval under Staff Approved items (see below).

An application, slate assessment, and photographs have been submitted.

• Remove deteriorated slate roof.

• Install new CertainTeed “Carriage House” dimensional asphalt shingle roof.

• Install new metal ridge roll, flashing, and valleys; to be painted “Tinner’s Red”.

15. 11-5 –36

565 South Fourth Street

Bob Althoff (Applicant/ Owner)

An application and photographs have been submitted.

Install New Privacy Fence

• Remove the existing composite board privacy fence.

• Install new Hardi Plank privacy fence in same location as existing fence.

• New fence to be of the same dimension and color as the existing fence.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

Jerome & Marianne Smith (Owners)

Approve Application #11-5-1, 787 South Third Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove existing asphalt shingle roof on hyphen.

• Install new GAF/Elk “Slateline” dimensional asphalt shingle roof on hyphen; color to be “English Gray Slate”.

• Repair existing slate roof section as needed to match existing.

• Install new copper flashing and valley.

• All venting to be underneath ridge roll.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the hyphen roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Shingle to be GAF/Elk “Slateline” dimensional asphalt shingle roof; color to be “English Gray Slate”.

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

Repair Slate Roof

• Replace any/all missing, damaged, and deteriorated slate on the main roof with new or used slate of the exact same color and profile and in accordance with all applicable City Code and industry standards.

• 11-5-2

258 Jackson Street

Rosalie Goodsell (Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-2, 258 Jackson Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove damaged non-historic front door.

• Install new half-lite front door per submitted cutsheet; to be stained “Dark Brown”.

Install New Door

• Install new, solid core door in existing door jamb at front entry. New door to be half-lite wood door.

• Set on 1 1/2 pair 3 1/2″ x 3 1/2″ butt hinges; hinge locations to be determined by the existing jamb.

• Wood units to be stained or painted; finish all six sides.

• 11-5-3

299 East Livingston Avenue

Wayne F. Hiles (Applicant) Rose K. Vargo Tr. (Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-3, 299 E. Livingston Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA#10-1-3, 299 E. Livingston Avenue, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Expired: 2-2-11.

Approve Application #10-1-3, 299 East Livingston Avenue, as submitted with the following clarifications:

• Replace brick wall per submitted drawings.

• The top course of the new wall is to be laid as a Soldier Course.

• The eastern end of the new wall is to return to the structure.

• The west side of the wall is to be no higher than three feet tall (3’), and the existing six-foot (6’) wall section in this location is to be removed.

• The applicant is to match the existing brick as closely as possible, submitting a brick sample and revised design to HPO Staff prior for final review and approval prior to issuance of Certificate of Appropriateness.

MOTION: Colvin/Ours (7-0-0) APPROVED.

• 11-5-4

756 South Third Street

Urban Order Architecture (Applicant) Dan Berglund (Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-4, 756 South Third Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA#09-10-23, 756 South Third Street, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Expired: 10-6-10.

Approve Application #09-10-23, 756 South Third Street, as submitted with the following clarifications:

• Conversion of existing two-family dwelling into a single-family home. (The residence was originally constructed as a single-family and was converted in the 1940s or 1950s).

• Remove vinyl siding and restore/repair stucco underneath.

• Remove metal awnings and vinyl shutters.

• Remove existing vinyl windows on severely altered rear addition, and install new Marvin all-wood windows and doors per submitted drawings.

• Existing windows on historic front portion of house are to be repaired.

• The three (3) historic windows on west elevation are to be repaired.

• The two (2) original windows on the first floor on south elevation are to be repaired.

• Marvin sash packs are to be installed on the second floor of the south elevation.

• New low-profile storm windows are to be installed replacing the existing storm windows.

• Install new fence and gate per submitted drawing.

• Siding is to be removed from any/all areas to determine condition underneath on both the original house and addition.

MOTION: Straker/Colvin (7-0-0) APPROVED.

• 11-5-5

1054 Jaeger Street

Dehlco Construction Services (Applicant) Mark Mitchell (Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-5, 1054 Jaeger Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Repair/replace deteriorated wood siding as needed to match existing per submitted specifications.

• Paint residence: siding of rear wood-sided addition to be Sherwin Williams “Tavern Taupe” (SW7508);

windows and trim on masonry portion to be Sherwin Williams “Tavern Taupe” (SW7508); additional trim to be Sherwin Williams “Zurich White” (SW7626).

Repair/Replace Wood Siding

• Repair/replace all wood siding and trim as needed to match existing, in-kind, like-for-like.

• Prepare all wood siding and trim surfaces using the appropriate hand tools.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish coat all exterior wooden surfaces with exterior paint according to manufacturer’s specifications.

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 11-5-6b

1054 Pearl Street

Dehlco Construction Services (Applicant) Grand Canal Properties, LLC (Owner)

Application #11-5-6has been divided into item ‘a’ for German Village Commission review under New Business (see above), and item ‘b’ for Staff Approval under Staff Approved items.

Approve Application #11-5-6, 1054 Pearl Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove deteriorated rubber membrane roof on rear shed roof addition.

• Install new EPDM rubber membrane roof to match existing.

Install New Rubber Roof

• Remove any/all asphalt shingles or rolled roofing on the rear addition down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.

• Replace any/all deteriorated and damaged wood fascia with new wood of same dimension as necessary. Prime and finish coat all wood fasçia prior to the installation of all new gutter and down spouts; color to match the existing trim color. Paint color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff.

• 11-5-7

660-662 Jaeger Street

Todd R. Canei (Applicant) Wallace F. Ackley Co. (Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-7, 660-662 Jaeger Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove deteriorated rubber membrane roof on main roof and make any/all repairs to decking as needed.

• Install new EPDM rubber membrane roof to match existing.

• Reinstall existing ceramic tile parapet cap/coping to match existing.

Install New Rubber Roof

• Remove any/all asphalt shingles or rolled roofing on the rear addition down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.

• 11-5-8

544 South 4th Street

Superior Home Maintenance Company (Applicant) Michael Rourke (Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-8, 544 South 4th Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing, GAF, Royal Sovereign, Nickel Gray, 3-tab shingles. All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• 11-5-9

606 Rader Alley

Colleen M. O’Donnell (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-9, 606 Rader Alley, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint colors to be “Old Glory Blue” on the body of the house and “White” on trim, as per submitted paint chips.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

Porch Rehabilitation

• Remove any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing tongue and groove, wooden porch flooring.

• Repair and/or replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing floor joists with new wooden floor joists of the appropriate dimension and in accordance with all applicable City Building Codes and industry standards.

• It is recommended that all new, tongue and groove, porch flooring be primed on all sides with porch floor enamel thinned with the appropriate material according to manufacturers’ specifications prior to installation in order to extend its useful life.

• Install new, tongue and groove wooden, porch flooring.

• Following installation of the new, wooden flooring, apply no less than one (1), complete, finish coat of the same exterior porch floor enamel thinned with the appropriate material according to manufacturers’ specifications. Paint color to be “Falcon,” per submitted paint chip.

• 11-5-10

39 East Sycamore Street

Michael A. Eckholt (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-10, 39 East Sycamore Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing, GAF, Royal Sovereign, Nickel Gray, 3-tab shingles.

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• 11-5-11

825 South Fifth Street

Deane VonStein/Michael Hahn (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-11, 825 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install New Storm Door

• Install a new, Andersen 3000 Series, Full View, clear glass storm door with dual-pane thermal insulating glass at front entrance, per the submitted cut sheet.

• Color to be “white.”

• Hardware to be brass.

• 11-5-12

130-132 Jackson Street

David Ward/510 Lazelle, Ltd. (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application 11-5-12, 130-132 E. Jackson Street, for renewal of expired COA # 09-5-15 (Expired: April 28, 2010), exactly as previously approved, for a period of one (1) year.

• Replace siding on both dormers with cedar lap siding per submitted photos.

• Siding to be 4” exposure, and to be installed horizontally on sides of dormers.

• Finished work to be painted to match existing.

Remove and Replace Siding

• Remove the existing damaged siding from the two dormers.

• Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Repair/replace any/all original, existing wood siding with any/all new wood siding per the submitted photo.

• Any/all repaired/replaced exterior trim elements (i. e. window & door trim, corner boards, eave soffit & fascia, crown moldings, etc.) to be restored to the original profile and dimension as determined by any/all existing, original trim and/or shadow lines following the removal of the damaged siding and any/all non-original trim repair patches.

• Prepare all exterior wooden surfaces on all elevations of the building using the appropriate hand tools.

• Solid prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Finish color schedule to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval in consultation with the German Village Commission.

• 11-5-13

504-506 S. Lazelle Street

David Ward/510 Lazelle, Ltd. (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-13, 504-506 S. Lazelle Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the front and rear dormers down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing, GAF, Royal Sovereign, or Certain Teed, Nickel Gray, 3-tab shingles.

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red.”

• 11-5-14

510-512 Lazelle Street

David Ward/510 Lazelle, Ltd. (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application 11-5-14, 510-512 Lazelle Street, for renewal of expired COA # 08-1-8 (Expired: December 31, 2008), exactly as previously approved, for a period of one (1) year.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to

Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as

necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged and deteriorated metal valleys with new metal valleys of appropriate dimension, as

necessary. Valleys are to be smooth not a “W” channel to maintain the appropriate historic appearance and

profile.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Style: Color:

[ ] GAF Slateline (dimensional) [ ] English Gray Slate

[ ] Weathered Slate

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s

Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• 11-5-15

123 Lansing Street

Thomas Baker (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-15, 123 Lansing Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the house and garage for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint colors for the body of the house and the garage door will be Valspar “Empire.” Trim will be Valspar “Muslin Wrap.”

• Shutter and front entrance door to be repainted “black.”

• The parged foundation to be painted Valspar “Empire.”

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• 11-5-16

714 South Sixth Street

Klaus J. Gauer (Applicant) Jeff & Regina Tobin (Owners)

Approve Application #11-5-16, 714 South Sixth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Porch Rehabilitation

• Remove any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing tongue and groove, wooden porch flooring.

• Install new, tongue and groove wooden, porch flooring.

• Restore the front porch banisters/hand rails/columns as necessary with like material of exact same dimension and profile as the existing, original, front porch banisters/hand rails/columns; like-for-like.

• 11-5-17

792 Mohawk Street

Seth Seymour (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-17, 792 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Paint color will be Behr, #730D-5 “Village Square”: Window trim, soffits/fascia, gutters/downspouts, rear cellar doors, vents, and rear yard privacy fence.

• Front and rear doors to be painted Behr, # S-H-790 “Black Suede.”

• The previously painted (white), parged stone foundation will be painted Behr, #730D-5,“Village Square”

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

Exterior Lighting

• Install a new exterior light fixture to the right of the front entrance door.

• Fixture to be electric, copper, Gas Light Company brand “Jackson Square,” 18” x 10”, per the submitted work specifications.

11-5-18

866 South Fifth Street

D. Kirk Marker (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-18, 866 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Exterior Painting

• Power wash the aluminum siding on the house. Pressure is not to exceed 300 lb./p.s.i. and utilizing a broad fan tip.

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint colors are per the submitted paint color chips.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

Landscaping

• Remove existing ivy and shrubs in front yard and remove ivy from the house. To avoid damage to the siding, the ivy should be cut from the bottom and allowed to die before removing.

• Install new front yard, side yard, and alley landscaping, per the submitted drawing.

• 11-5-19

762 South Fifth Street

Patricia Hook (Applicant/Owner)

Remove Existing Sidewalks and Install New Sidewalks

• Remove any/all damaged and deteriorated, concrete public and service sidewalks, and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• Maintain any/all existing sandstone curbs, and repair, as necessary, in accordance with all applicable industry standards, and/or replace with like sandstone curbing.

• 11-5-20

573 South Sixth Street

Craig D. & Constance H. Walley (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-20, 573 South Sixth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair/Replace Existing Fence

• Repair/replace the existing, wooden, board-on-board privacy fence along Berger Alley on the south side of the property with new wood fence of exact same profile and dimension, per submitted drawing and photographs.

• New fence stain to match existing stain, or new stain color to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of stain.

• 11-5-21

739 South Third Street

Scot Draughn (Applicant) American Blue Ribbon Holdings, Inc. (Owner)

Approve Application #11-5-21, 739 South Third Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove existing louver on window opening on third floor south elevation and install new all-wood window to match existing windows per submitted specifications; new unit to be painted to match existing.

• Remove existing steel utility door on north elevation; install new wood 4-panel door and stain to match existing exterior woodwork; louvered panel above utility door to remain.

• Remove existing non-code-compliant concrete pad at service door (north elevation); install new code-compliant 5’x5’ concrete pad and re-work existing brick pavers around pad to create gradual slope to concrete pad per submitted siteplan and specifications.

Install New Window

• Replace one non-original, non-contributing louver on the third floor of the north elevation with a new, 2-OVER-2, wood windows of appropriate dimension and profile and to fit the original openings exactly. Window to be per cutsheet submitted to the H. P. O. staff.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing casing and/or sill with new wood of appropriate dimension and profile.

• Prepare, prime, and paint all casings and sills in accordance with industry standards.

Install New Door

• Install new, solid core door in existing door jamb on north elevation.

• New door to be either a four-panel wood door. Set on 1 1/2 pair 3 1/2″ x 3 1/2″ butt hinges; hinge locations to be determined by the existing jamb.

• Wood units to be stained or painted; finish all six sides. Exterior and hinged sides of fiberglass and metal doors to be painted. Interior and keyed sides of fiberglass and metal doors to be either painted or stained.

• Paint/stain color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint/stain.

• 11-5-22

257 Lansing Street

Brita Larsen (Applicant/Owner)

Renewal of an Expired COA

Approve Application 11-5-22a, 257 Lansing Street, for renewal of expired COA # 09-10-8b (Expired: October 5, 2010), exactly as previously approved, for a period of one (1) year.

Replace Deteriorated/Non-Original Windows

• Replace all deteriorated/non-original, non-contributing windows on the front elevation as per City Staff determination.

• Install new, 2-over-2, wood windows of appropriate dimension and profile to fit the original openings exactly. Window brochure or cutsheet to be submitted to the H. P. O. staff for final review and approval prior to installation.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing gutter with new gutters of appropriate dimension.

• Replace any damaged, deteriorated, missing soffit or fasçia with new wood of appropriate dimension as necessary.

• Prepare, prime, and paint all windows and soffit/fasçia trim.

• Replace five (5) existing windows, four on the front, and one on the second floor, with all wood windows, two-over-two.

Install New Privacy Fence

• Install new 6’ wood privacy fence along per submitted design and site plan. Fence to be painted or stained within one (1) year. Stain/paint color for all fence to be submitted to the Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

• Replace approximately 44 feet of existing fence and front gate to match existing structurally sound fence.

Replace Porch Flooring

• Remove and dispose of all existing flooring; pull all nails from, and inspect condition of, existing joists to insure structural integrity.

• Install [ ] 1″ x 3″ or [ ] 1″ x 6″ tongue and groove, yellow pine, porch decking.

• Blind nail with galvanized finish nails only.

• Allow a 1 1/2″ minimum to 2 1/2″ maximum flooring overhang on all outside edges.

• Install exterior grade, quarter-round moulding to band board fascia, tight against all flooring overhang.

• Paint color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

Replace Porch Ceiling

• Remove and dispose of existing porch ceiling, pull all nails from, and inspect condition of, existing rafters to insure structural integrity.

• Install a new porch ceiling nailed with galvanized finish nails.

• New material to be [ ] 1″ x 3″, tongue and groove, yellow pine, bead board or [ ] 4′ x 8′ Georgia-Pacific “Classic” style Ply-Bead (with sanded surface and 1/8″ beaded pattern approx. 1.6″ o.c.); prime exposed surface complete.

• Paint/stain color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

• Replace front concrete step leading to the porch with same dimensions and material.

Replace Existing Concrete Steps

• Remove existing concrete front step and dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Install new concrete in the exact same location and of the exact same dimension, as necessary.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable City Building Codes.

• 11-5-23

785 City Park Avenue

Michael A. Thompson & Dennis D. Giglio (Applicant/Owner)

Replace Existing Fence with New Fence

VII. OLD BUSINESS

VIII. NEW BUSINESS

IX. ADJOURNMENT

Commission Agenda 04/05/11

jgraichen — Wed, 30 Mar 2011 14:31:06 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

April 5, 2011

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, April 26, 2011.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, May 3, 2011.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, March 1, 2011.

V. PUBLIC FORUM

VI. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

CONTINUED APPLICATIONS

1. 11-3-11

210 Thurman Avenue

Behal, Sampson, Dietz (Applicant)/ Rebecca Milnes (Owner)

An application, revised drawings, material samples, siteplan, and photographs have been submitted.

• Rehabilitation of storefront (see packet for details).

• Installation of awnings.

• Signage and lighting installation.

The following is taken from the Unapproved March 1, 2011 German Village Commission Meeting Minutes:

Continue Application #11-3-11, 210 Thurman Avenue, to allow the applicant time to submit additional information:

• Cover existing ruined brick with thin brick and match mortar as closely as possible.

• Install new “historic” wood storefront windows and doors per submitted drawings.

• Install painted wood wall signs and associated lighting for the retail spaces.

• Remove garage door on Jaeger Street side (west elevation) and replace with iron gate system for proposed courtyard.

• Remove apartment entrance door and install new wood window per submitted drawings.

• Repair wood windows as needed to match existing, and install new wood storm windows.

• Repair and repaint existing basement window (west elevation).

• Tuckpoint building as needed to match existing.

MOTION: Thiell/Durst (7-0-0) CONTINUED.

Commissioner Comments

• The Commission discussed the differences between restoration and being “new”.

• The Commission discussed the proposed use of thin-brick, the use of other materials, and alternative treatments.

• Commissioner Colvin – the current proposal would be appropriate.

• Commissioner Ours – either the project should be a restoration of the historic building or be a new contemporary design.

• Commissioner Durst – agrees with other commissioners; the offset dimension is problematic.

• Commissioner Case – the proposed thin-brick is okay, but it should somehow be differentiated from the existing brick.

NEW APPLICATIONS

2. 11-4-18

943-945 City Park Avenue

Phil Barger (Owner)

An application, cutsheet, and photographs have been submitted.

• Remove deteriorated hinged garage doors.

• Install 8’ x 7’ flush wood overhead doors.

• Remove existing asphalt shingles above garage doors and install new 1’ x 6’ cedar siding; to be painted “Keystone Gray”.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30 PM

3. 11-4-19

838 South Third Street

Kay Ann Homoelle – Property Manager (Applicant)/ Thomas Lamb (Owner)

Work has been undertaken prior to approval, and an exterior Code Violation has been issued.

An application has been submitted.

• Installation of satellite dish in front yard.

4. 11-4-20

791 South Sixth Street

Sullivan Builders (Applicant)/ Stuart Hunter (Owner)

An application and photographs have been submitted.

• Remove existing wood siding on garage; install new board and batten siding to match siding on rear addition of residence.

• Install new garage roof to match residence.

5. 11-4-21

803 South Fifth Street

Mallory Pools (Applicant)/ Gail Evans (Owner)

An application, siteplan, and drawing have been submitted.

• Construct in-ground 5’ x 25’ swimming pool.

• Pool deck to be brick reused from existing patio.

• Pool mechanicals to be installed in existing detached garage.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:00 PM

6. 11-4-22

188 East Whittier Street

Caren Petersen (Applicant)/ Duncan Highland Moors Holdings, Ltd. (Owner)

An application, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

• Install 36”x 24”x 1” PVC hanging sign on wall mounted brackets per submitted drawings; “Muse Gallery”.

• Install 50”x 9” wall sign; “Muse Gallery”.

• Install 24”x 13” adhered vinyl letter “Muse Gallery” inside storefront window.

• Install 14”x 3” adhered vinyl letter “Embrace Art” inside storefront window.

7. 11-4-23

190 East Whittier Street

Caren Petersen (Applicant)/ Duncan Highland Moors Holdings, Ltd. (Owner)

An application, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

• Install 36”x 24”x 1” PVC hanging sign on wall mounted brackets per submitted drawings; “Circle Galleries”.

• Install 56”x 9” x 1” wall sign; “Circle Galleries”.

• Install 20”x 19” adhered vinyl letter “Circle Galleries” inside storefront window.

• Install 21”x 8” adhered vinyl letter “Exclusive Fine Art….” inside storefront window.

• Install metal security door with integrated signage on side entry door; two (2) options supplied.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:30 PM

8. 11-4-24

574 South Sixth Street

Craig W. Murdick Architect, Ltd. (Applicant)/ Brad Ostroff (Owner)

An application, siteplan, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

• Construct rear second-floor bedroom addition above existing single-story; demolishing existing gable roof.

• Construct gable roof on existing flat-roof rear addition; including small gable roof above existing patio door.

• Materials proposed – GAF/Elk 3-Tab shingles, Semco wood windows, Hardi-plank smooth lap siding.

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW

9. 11-4-25

219 East Beck Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant)/ Phil Fankhauser (Owner)

An application, siteplan, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Conceptual Review

• Construction of rear 2-story frame addition to existing 2-story brick double.

• Construction of 1-story connector.

• Construction of freestanding 2-car garage.

10. 11-4-26

797 South Sixth Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant)/ Craig Kent & Erin Crotty (Owners)

An application, siteplan, drawings, and photographs have been submitted.

Conceptual Review

• Construction of rear 2-story frame addition to existing 2½-story frame house.

• Demolish non-original 1-story rear addition.

• Construct 1-story and 2-story connector.

STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS

11. 11-4-17a

180 Reinhard Avenue

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant)/ Schiller Park, LLC (Owner)

Application #11-4-18 has been divided into item ‘a’ for German Village Commission review under New Business, and

item ‘b’ for Staff Approval under Staff Approved items (see below).

An application, siteplan, cutsheets, and photographs have been submitted.

• Install new gas light on 6’-6” pole per submitted cutsheets.

• Pole to be located 2’-0” north of existing wrought iron fence.

12. 11-4-27

495 South Fourth Street

Chris Crader (Applicant)/ Rosemarie Keidel (Owner)

An application, drawing, and photographs have been submitted.

• Install 8” square 16-gauge welded duct for venting of pizza oven on east elevation (alley).

• Option 1: galvanized steel with painted seams.

• Option 2: black iron with option of covering with fireproof paint.

• Work to be performed by Amerifast Heating & Air-Conditioning.

• Duct will not be visible from Livingston Avenue or Fourth Street.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 11-4-1

180 Thurman Avenue

Seth Clarke (Applicant)/ Adam Fazio & Karl Whittington (Owners)

Approve Application #11-4-1, 180 Thurman Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove existing asphalt shingle roof.

• Install new CertainTeed Standard 3-tab asphalt shingle roof; color to be “Nickel Gray”.

• Install new metal ridge roll, flashings, and valleys; color to be either “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray”.

• All venting to be underneath ridge roll.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles.

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 11-4-2

495 City Park Avenue

Stephen Smelko (Applicant) George Shumm (Owner)

Approve Application #11-4-2, 495 City Park Avenue, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Install New Slate Roof Shingles

• Remove existing, original, deteriorated ribbon slate shingles, which are beyond their serviceable life, down to the sheathing.

• Dispose of any/all debris per Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with new wood of appropriate dimension as necessary.

• Install new slate roof shingles of exact same style, color and profile as original; like-for-like.

• Install metal ridge roll; color to be ‘Tinner’s Red”.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.

Repair Chimney

• Repair one (1) existing, parged, brick chimney in accordance with industry standards and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.

• Check all mortar joints on chimney for soundness. All sound mortar to remain in place. Use hand tools to remove any/all loose mortar to a depth of 3/4″, moisten surface with water, and spot point as needed with mortar of matching color, texture, hardness, and joint profile. New mortar must be softer than the brick, and no harder than the historic mortar, to allow for expansion and contraction of the brick. Original mortar mix was composed of 1 part lime to 2 parts sand. White portland cement may be substituted for up to (but no more than) 20 percent of the lime content. (Refer to Preservation Brief 2- “Repointing Mortar in Historic Brick Buildings”)

• Parging to match the existing parged chimney in color and texture; like-for-like.

• 11-4-3

238-238 ½ East Whittier Street

Austin Logue (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-4-3, 238-238 ½ East Whittier Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair Underground Water Line

• Make any/all necessary site preparations to replace the existing, deteriorated, and damaged water supply line from the alley tap to the main supply at meter inside the residence.

• Complete the necessary plumbing installation per Columbus City Building Code and with any/all required inspections.

• All trenching to be back filled, leveled and reseeded where lawn exists.

• All trenching to be back filled and all cement pad and/or sidewalks to be replaced in same location and same dimensions; like-for-like.

• 11-4-4

306 East Sycamore Street

Karen A. Lambert & Kasey K. Welch (Owners)

Approve Application #11-4-4, 306 East Sycamore Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove deteriorated, non-operable, and non-historic overhead single garage door.

• Install new overhead single garage door per submitted cutsheet.

• 11-4-5

136 East Whittier Street

Chase Bank/Attn.: Corey Barnes (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #11-4-5, 306 East Whittier Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

Repair Damaged Slate Roof

• Install temporary tarp system to prevent ongoing deterioration following recent storm damage in accordance with industry standards and Columbus City Building Code requirements.

• Dispose of any/all debris per Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with new wood of appropriate dimension as necessary.

• Install new slate roof shingles of exact same style, color and profile as original; like-for-like.

• Install metal ridge roll; color to be ‘Tinner’s Red”.

• All work to be in accordance with industry standards and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.

• 11-4-6

792 South Fifth Street

Rich & Janet Dawson (Owners)

Approve Application #11-4-6, 792 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Renew COA#10-3-11, 792 South Fifth Street, exactly as previously approved for a period of one (1) year. Expired: 3-2-11.

Approve Application #10-3-11, 792 South Fifth Street, as submitted with the following clarifications:

• Construct a garage per submitted drawings.

• Use 4” lap siding in lieu of the proposed 8” lap siding.

• The overhang is to meet the requirements of city code.

• The window trim per guidelines, page 78, in lieu of mitered trim.

• One (1) course of split face CMU at the top of the foundation, color to be “grey.”

• Light fixtures per submitted cutsheets.

• The man door on the west elevation shall be a four (4) panel wood door with trim per the guidelines.

• The garage doors shall have the applied trim per the submitted elevations.

• There shall be a half-round gutter on the rear of the garage with the eave detail per the guidelines.

• The maximum height shall be 12’-0” at the alley side of the garage.

MOTION: Colvin/Thiell (6-0-0) APPROVED.

• 11-4-7

792 South Fifth Street

A 2nd Estimate, Ltd. (Applicant)/ Rich & Janet Dawson (Owners)

Approve Application #11-4-7, 792 South Fifth Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Tear off flat roof (approximately 455-sqft) on one-story section down to sheeting.

• Repair/replace any damaged sheeting.

• Install new EDPM rubber roof.

Install New Rubber Roof

• Remove any/all asphalt shingles or rolled roofing down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.

• Replace any/all deteriorated and damaged wood fascia with new wood of same dimension as necessary. Prime and finish coat all wood fasçia prior to the installation of all new gutters and down spouts; color to match the existing trim color. Paint color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff.

• 11-4-8

932 Mohawk Street

Eric Hamilton (Owner)

Approve Application #11-4-8, 932 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted:

• Remove existing shingle roof.

• Install new CertainTeed standard 3-Tab asphalt shingle roof; color to be “Nickel Gray”.

• Install new metal ridge roll, valleys, and flashing; color to be either “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray”.

• Reline box gutters with rubber membrane, all work to match existing.

• Repair/replace deteriorated soffit on front elevation as needed to match existing, in kind, like-for-like.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. Shingle to be CertainTeed standard 3-Tab; color to be “Nickel Gray”.

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

Repair Box Gutters

• Examine all box gutters on the main house and make any repairs and/or replace the existing box gutter system on all elevations with new materials of appropriate dimension and profile.

• Reline with new copper, terne metal, galvanized metal, or E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes.

• Install new, round, galvanized metal downspouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.

Eave, Soffit & Fascia Repair

• Repair and or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood eave soffit and fascia on all elevations as necessary with new wood of exact same profile and dimension; like-for-like.

• 11-4-9

926 Mohawk Street

Jerry Smith (Owner)

Approve Application #11-4-9, 926 Mohawk Street, as submitted with all clarifications noted: