German Village Society » Commission

Commission Agenda, 08/03/10

jgraichen — Wed, 28 Jul 2010 00:50:18 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA
August 3, 2010
4:00 p.m.
German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

Applicants or their representatives must attend this hearing. If applicants are absent, it is likely that the application will be continued until the Commission’s next hearing. If you have any questions, please call the city’s Historic Preservation Office at 645-8620 or 645-7920.A Sign Language Interpreter to “Sign” this hearing will be made available for anyone with a need for this service. Sign language interpreters must be schedule by calling 645-8620 or TDD 645-3293 at least forty-eight (48) hours prior to the scheduled hearing.

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, August 31, 2010.
109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, September 7, 2010.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, July 6, 2010.

V. PUBLIC FORUM

VI. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

CONTINUED APPLICATIONS

1.   10-6-19
799 South Fifth Street
Jon Humphress (Applicant)/ Helen Kinnamon Trust (Owner)
An application and photographs have been submitted.
•   Remove slate on south slope only.
•   Replace with CertainTeed “Symphony” composite slate shingles.

The following is taken from the Unapproved June 1, 2010 German Village Commission Meeting Minutes:
Continue Application #10-6-19, South Fifth Street:
• Remove slate on south slope only.
• Replace with CertainTeed “Symphony” composite slate shingles.
MOTION: Ours/Case (6-0-0) CONTINUED.

2.   10-7-23
147 East Deshler Avenue
George Skestos (Applicant)/The 147 E. Deshler Ave. Trust (Owner)
An application, revised drawings, and photographs have been submitted.
•   Replacement of the existing deteriorated brick garden walls, iron railing and columns with new brick columns, iron fencing and garden wall. Brick to match the existing.
•   Addition of new sandstone entry columns and iron gate. Sandstone will match existing accents found on the house.
•   Replacement of the existing entry sidewalk brick with brick to match the new columns and garden wall.
•   Replacement of the existing concrete entry sidewalk steps with new sandstone treads with brick risers to match the house and garden wall materials.
•   Replacement of the existing hardscape within the garden walls, per submitted drawing (C1.1).
•   Replacement of the existing planting within the garden walls, per submitted drawing (C1.1).

The following is taken from the Unapproved July 6, 2010 German Village Commission Meeting Minutes:
Continue Application #10-8-23,147 East Deshler Avenue:
•   Height of fencing and hedge in front of the northwest (front) of the property is an issue.
•   Discussion regarding the overall design and materials used for the entry of property from the sidewalk at front entry.
•   Discussion regarding how the columns and fence engage the existing fence at the northeast side of the property.
•   Column cap details may be too ornate.
•   Details about how the fencing engages the house on 4th Street.
•   Look at material used for steps and columns.
MOTION: Case/Colvin (5-0-1) CONTINUED. [Ours]

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30 PM

NEW APPLICATIONS

3.   10-8-8a
796 South Fifth Street
Scott Motley and Martha Brewer (Applicants/Owners)
Application #10-8-Xa have been divided into item ‘a’ for German Village Commission review and item ‘b’ for Staff Approval under Staff Approved items (see below).
An application and photographs have been submitted.
•   Install window boxes. Three on the front and 2 on the side of the house.
•   Photographs of two alternatives have been submitted. The first option is an iron, fence style window box. The second option is basic, wooden window box.

4.   10-8-12
874 Lazelle Street
Sharon Killworth (Applicant/Owner)
An application and photographs have been submitted.
•   Remove and replace front, concrete steps with like material.
•   Install two new iron railings similar to the railings shown in the submitted picture located at 921 South Third Street.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:00 PM

5.   10-8-13
201 East Whittier Street
Casey James Covrett (Applicant/Owner)
An application, photographs, fence cutsheet have been submitted.
•   Re-side residence with 4-inch Hardiplank siding (preferred material), or beveled cedar 4-inch lap siding (second choice).
•   Paint new siding the same color that is currently on the house, Hunter Green with white trim.
•   Install 28 linear feet of 6-foot tall wrought iron fence in side yard. Fence to be Fortin “F5.”

6. 10-8-14
310 Alexander Alley
Roger P. Sugarman (Applicant)/Alexander Alley LLC (Owner)
An application, photographs and cutsheet have been submitted.
• Replace two second floor windows with double hung, wood windows as per submitted specifications.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 5:30 PM

STAFF RECOMMENDATION

7.   10-8-15
703 South Fifth Street
Harvey Handler (Applicant/Owner)
An application has been submitted.
•   Renew Certificate of Appropriateness #08-10-16, 703 South Fifth Street, for construction of new dining room addition on north elevation exactly as previously approved for the period of one (1) year. Expired: September 29, 2009.
•   This is the second renewal. The original Certificate of Appropriateness # 07-09-07 was issued on September 11, 2007.

8. 10-8-16
81 East Whittier Street
Beesign Signs Inc. (Applicant)/Mike Ferris Properties (Owner)
An application, front elevation and sign specification sheet have been submitted.
• Installation of red and white cut vinyl lettering and logo to be applied on the inside surface of a front office window per submitted specifications.

9.   10-8-17
551 South Grant Avenue
Eric P. Stephens (Applicant)/David Stump (Owner)
An application, photographs and slate assessment have been submitted.
•   Replace the existing slate roof with 3-tab asphalt shingles from the approved shingle list, GAF Slateline, color to be “English Gray.”
•   Repair/replace existing box gutters to match existing per submitted specifications.

STAFF APPROVALS
(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

•   10-8-1
873 Mohawk Street
Tim Petroff (Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-1, 873 Mohawk Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Paint residence: main body to be Olympic “Sprig of Ivy” (S68-3), Trim to be Olympic “Bone White” (D20-3).
Exterior Painting
•   Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.
•   Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.
•   Glaze and caulk as necessary.
•   Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.
•   Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.
•   Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.
•   Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

•   10-8-2
877 Mohawk Street
Cheryl Brown (Owners)
Approve Application #10-8-2, 877 Mohawk Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Remove existing section of deteriorated fence per submitted drawings and photographs.
Install New Privacy Fence
•   Install new 6’ wood privacy fence along per submitted design. Fence to be painted or stained within one (1) year. Stain/paint color for all fence to be submitted to the Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

•   10-8-3
720 Lazelle Street
James J. Wolf (Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-3, 720 Lazelle Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof
•   Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.
•   Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.
•   Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.
•   Replace any/all damaged and deteriorated metal valleys with new metal valleys of appropriate dimension, as necessary. Valleys are to be smooth not a “W” channel to maintain the appropriate historic appearance and profile.
•   Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.
•   Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles. New shingle to be GAF “Slateline” dimensional asphalt shingle; color to be English Gray Slate or Weathered Slate.
•   All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”
•   Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”
•   Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

•   10-8-4
596 South Sixth Street
Bcf Design and Development Ltd. (Applicant)/William Case and Lisa Atkins Case (Owners)
Approve Application #10-8-4, 596 South Sixth Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
Fascia Repair
•   Repair and or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood eave fascia on all elevations as necessary with new wood of exact same profile and dimension; like-for-like.
Exterior Wood Trim and Shutter Painting
•   Prepare all exterior wooden surfaces for painting using the appropriate hand tools. Repair/replace all missing, damaged, and deteriorated wood as necessary according to industry standards. All replacement wood to be of same profile and dimension as the original; like-for-like.
•   Prime all bare and new wood with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications.
•   Owner has the option of selecting one (1) of the following appropriate painting methods: a) paint all wood trim, windows, doors, etc. the exact same color as currently exists on the wood trim or, b) submit a new paint schedule to the Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

•   10-8-5
581 Lathrop Street
Jonathan and Anna Striker (Applicant) Greg Lewis (Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-5, 581 Lathrop Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Paint residence: main body to be Sherwin Williams “Sea Serpent” (SW7615), Trim to be Sherwin Williams “Extra White” (SW7006).
•   Scrape, repair, reglaze and paint all windows per submitted specifications.
Power Wash Spec
•   Clean all unpainted masonry in accordance with industry standards and Columbus City Codes. Pressure is not to exceed 300 lb./p.s.i. and utilizing a broad fan tip. Should chemical cleaning be proposed by the owner or contractor or be determined to be necessary by Historic Preservation Office staff for paint removal of Previously Painted Masonry: the following procedure is required: Using the most diluted solution possible, perform a patch test by chemically cleaning a two foot by two foot (2′ x2′) section in the least visible location possible. Following the application of the approved cleaning solution, the entire area that has been treated is to be rinsed with water in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations. If air pressure is needed for either the cleaning or the rinsing procedures, only a broad fan tip is to be used and the pressure is not to exceed 300 lb/psi. (Refer to Preservation Brief 1- “The Cleaning and Waterproof Coating of Masonry Buildings”).
Exterior Painting
•   Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.
•   Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.
•   Glaze and caulk as necessary.
•   Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.
•   Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.
•   Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.
•   Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.
Repair Windows
•   Examine all windows on all elevations and make all necessary repairs to insure proper operation of upper and lower sashes.
•   Any/all original wood windows are to be repaired in accordance with industry standards for wood windows.
•   Repair all double-hung, wood windows as needed with new materials of exact same dimension and profile; like-for-like.
Repair / Replace Exterior Casings & Sills
•   Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing casing and/or sill with new wood of appropriate dimension and profile.
•   Prepare, prime, and paint all casings and sills in accordance with industry standards.

•   10-8-6
874 Macon Alley
Tiffany Riemenschreider – Able Roofing (Applicant)/Andy Callif (Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-6, 874 Macon Alley, with all clarifications as indicated:
Install New Rubber Roof
•   Remove any/all asphalt shingles or rolled roofing on the kitchen down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.
•   Examine all structural members of the flat roofing system from the square (i.e. top plate) to determine condition. Make any/all necessary structural repairs as needed in accordance with standard building practices and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.
•   Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.
•   Install new E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.
•   Replace any/all deteriorated and damaged wood fascia with new wood of same dimension as necessary. Prime and finish coat all wood fascia prior to the installation of all new gutter and down spouts; color to match the existing trim color. Paint color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff.

•   10-8-7
1120 South Pearl Street
Kara L. Miller (Applicant/Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-7, 1120 South Pearl Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Paint garage: main body to be Sherwin Williams “Quiver Tan” (SW 6151), Trim to be Sherwin Williams “Relaxed Khaki” (SW 6149).
Exterior Painting
•   Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.
•   Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.
•   Glaze and caulk as necessary.
•   Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.
•   Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.
•   Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.
•   Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

•   10-8-8b
796 South Fifth Street
Scott Motley and Martha Brewer (Applicants/Owners)
Application #10-8-8a has been divided into item ‘a’ for German Village Commission review (see above) and item ‘b’ for Staff Approval under Staff Approved items.
Approve Application #10-8-8b, 796 South Fifth Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Paint residence and garage one of the two following schemes.
•   Main body to be Sherwin Williams “Perfect Greige” (SW 6073), trim to be Sherwin Williams “Pacer White” (SW 6098) and doors and shutters to be Sherwin Williams “Distance” (SW 6243).
•   Main body to be Sherwin Williams “”Summit Gray” (SW 7669), trim to be Sherwin Williams “Pure White” (SW 7005) and doors and shutters to be “Greenblack” (SW 6994).
Exterior Painting
•   Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.
•   Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.
•   Glaze and caulk as necessary.
•   Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.
•   Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.
•   Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.
•   Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

•   10-8-9
255-293 Lear Street
Brian Stroh (Applicant)/Waldheim Condominium Association (Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-9, 255-293 Lear Street, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Replace portion of perimeter parking lot fence in accordance with the submitted siteplan.
•   Style and height shall conform to the pictures labeled Sections 2, 3 &4 submitted as part of this application.
•   Remove lattice from existing fence labeled Section 1a and 1b on siteplan.
•   Remove fence along Section 5 and do not replace.
•   Work on Sections 2, 3 and 4 as labeled on the siteplan is not approved. A new Certificate of Appropriateness will be required before work commences on these sections.
Install New Privacy Fence
•   Install new 6’ wood privacy fence along per submitted design and siteplan with the exception of Sections 2, 3 and 4 (as labeled on the siteplan). Fence to be painted or stained “Oxford Brown” within one (1) year.

•   10-8-10
296-298 Beck Street and 299-301 Berger Alley
Tina Jacobson (Applicant/Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-10, 296-298 Beck Street and 299-301 Berger Alley, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Paint two doubles that are located on the same parcel.
•   296 & 298 Beck Street – paint addition Sherwin Williams “Ramie” (SW6156), trim to be Sherwin Williams “Favorite Tan” (SW6157) and accents/door to be Sherwin Williams “Sawdust” (SW6158).
•   299 and 301 Berger Alley – paint main residence “Useful Gray” (SW7050), trim to be Sherwin Williams “Analytical Gray” (SW 7051) and accents/door to be “Gray Area” (SW 7052).
•   NOTE: No painting of existing unpainted masonry is approved at this time.
Exterior Painting
•   Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.
•   Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.
•   Glaze and caulk as necessary.
•   Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.
•   Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.
•   Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.
•   Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

•   10-8-11
117-121 East Livingston Avenue
Abe Bahgat (Applicant/Owner)
Approve Application #10-8-11, 117-121 East Livingston Avenue, with all clarifications as indicated:
•   Remove existing asphalt shingle roof and install new GAF/ELK “Royal Sovereign” 3-Tab shingles; color to be “Nickel Gray”..
•   Repair box gutters to match existing and per submitted specifications.
•   Remove and replace flat roof to match existing.
Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof
•   Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.
•   Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.
•   Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.
•   Replace any/all damaged and deteriorated metal valleys with new metal valleys of appropriate dimension, as necessary. Valleys are to be smooth not a “W” channel to maintain the appropriate historic appearance and profile.
•   Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.
•   Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab shingles.
•   All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”
•   Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”
•   Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.
Install New Rubber Roof
•   Remove any/all asphalt shingles or rolled roofing down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.
•   Examine all structural members of the flat roofing system from the square (i.e. top plate) to determine condition. Make any/all necessary structural repairs as needed in accordance with standard building practices and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.
•   Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.
•   Install new E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.
•   Replace any/all deteriorated and damaged wood fascia with new wood of same dimension as necessary. Prime and finish coat all wood fascia prior to the installation of all new gutter and down spouts; color to match the existing trim color. Paint color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff.
Repair Box Gutters
•   Examine all box gutters on the main roof and make any repairs and/or replace the existing box gutter system on all elevations with new materials of appropriate dimension and profile.
•   Reline with new copper, terne metal, galvanized metal, or E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes.
•   Install new, round, galvanized metal downspouts in the appropriate locations to assure proper drainage.
•   Examine the existing storm water drainage system for soundness and proper function. Make any/all necessary repairs to the existing storm sewer tile system to assure proper drainage away from the foundations of this and neighboring properties. If deemed necessary, install a French drain system or similar, appropriate drainage system in accordance with all applicable City Building Codes and industry standards.

VII. NEW BUSINESS – German Village Bylaws Revision: Article VI: Meetings: Subsection 5

Four (4) members shall constitute a quorum. The affirmative vote of no less than four (4) members of a simple majority of a seated quorum of commissioners shall be required for approval. A recommendation of the Commission may be made by a majority of those present. Upon presentation to at least a quorum of the Commission, the failure of a question to receive the required affirmative vote shall constitute denial of the application or recommendation against the requested action by the Commission.

VIII. OLD BUSINESS

IX. ADJOURNMENT

Commission Agenda 04/06/10

jgraichen — Mon, 05 Apr 2010 20:14:26 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

April 6, 2010

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, April 27, 2010.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, May 4, 2010.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES

• Tuesday, March 2, 2010

• Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Correction noted for Item #5, Application #10-2-13b, 684 City Park Avenue, clarification of reasons for denial.

10-2-13b

684 City Park Avenue

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant)/ Mark Becker (Owner)

Reasons for Denial

• CC3116.11(6) – Deteriorated architectural features shall be repaired rather than replaced whenever possible. In the event replacement is necessary, the new material shall match the material being replaced in composition, design, color, texture and other visual qualities. Repair or replacement of missing architectural features shall be based on accurate duplications of features, substantiated by historic, physical or pictorial evidence rather than on conjectural designs or the availability of different architectural elements from other structures.

• German Village Guideline Amendments – Window Replacement Criteria.

V. PUBLIC FORUM

VI. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

VARIANCE RECOMMENDATIONS

1. 10-4-15

529 South Lazelle Street

Jimmy Francis (Applicant) Matt Sharp (Unit A), Liz Alig (Unit B), Jimmy Francis (Unit C) (Owners)

An application, variance information and a site plan have been submitted.

• CC3332.037 – R-2F residential district – the building is currently a 3 unit dwelling.

• CC3332.05 – Area district lot width requirements – the current lot is 31.42 feet wide.

• CC3332.14 – R-2F area district requirements – the current lot is .0802 acres.

• CC3332.26 – Minimum side yard permitted – current side yard 2 feet on west side and 12 feet on east side.

• CC3332.27 – Rear yard – current rear yard ranges from 2 to 2.99 feet.

• CC3342.18 – Parking setback line – reduce parking setback to 0 feet.

• CC3342.28 – Minimum number of parking spaces required – current parking area has 3 spaces.

CONTINUED APPLICATIONS

2. 10-3-10

85 East Deshler Avenue

Janet Ward Druen (Applicant/Owner)

An application and photographs have been submitted.

• Add a one-over-one double-hung window and stone lintel, size to match adjacent windows, on the south side of the second floor at the rear of the house.

• The proposed additional window and lintel stone were removed from the first floor of the house when the addition was added to the rear of the house.

NEW APPLICATIONS

3. 10-4-16

299-301 East Livingston Avenue

Wayne Hiles & Thomas W. Vargo Trust (Applicants) Thomas W. Vargo Trust (Owner)

An application, photographs and slate assessment have been submitted.

• Replace the existing slate roof with 3-tab asphalt shingles from the approved shingle list, GAF/ELK Royal Sovereign, color to be “Nickel Gray.”

4. 10-4-17

541 South Third Street

Anne Fletcher (Applicant) Rosebud Realty, LLC (Owner)

An application, site plan and photographs have been submitted.

• Outdoor dining on the existing brick sidewalk adjacent to the store, per submitted photographs.

• Maximum of three (3) tables with four (4) chairs each.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:15 PM

5. 10-4-18

123 Deshler Avenue

Landfare Ltd. (Applicant) Rita J. Wolfe (Owner)

An application, site plans and photographs have been submitted.

• Install a 4’ x 14’ reflection pool, limestone coping and a bluestone patio, per submitted drawings.

• The reflection pool includes adjustable water sprays.

• The filtration unit is to be located on the southwest corner of the property, adjacent to the alley, per submitted drawing.

• Install four (4) dogwood trees per submitted drawing.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:30 PM

6. 10-4-19

684 City Park Avenue

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Mark Becker (Owner)

An application, site plan and photographs have been submitted.

• Construct driveway and parking court per submitted site plan.

• Install fence per submitted site plan and drawing.

• Install landscape planting per submitted site plan.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION

7. 10-4-20

53 East Sycamore Street

John Mikelson (Applicant) John & Patricia Mikelson (Owners)

An application and photographs have been submitted.

• Replace existing wooden gate with wrought iron gate, per submitted photographs.

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW APPLICATIONS

8. 10-4-21

180 Reinhard Avenue

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant) Tim Moore & Ken Hunger (Owners)

Conceptual Review

An application, site plan and photographs have been submitted.

• Construct a one car garage per submitted site plan and drawings. A variance will be required for a side yard reduction from three (3) feet to one (1) foot.

• Construct a new front porch to replace a porch removed in the 1970s. Discuss options for deck and columns.

THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE HEARD BEFORE 4:45 PM

9. 10-4-22

693 City Park Avenue

Gary J. Alexander, Architect (Applicant) Mr. & Mrs. Ron Hagan (Owners)

Conceptual Review

An application, site plan and photographs have been submitted.

• Demolish the existing family room, kitchen and rear porch.

• Construct a new family room, kitchen and rear porch per submitted drawings.

• Expand the existing carport to the north.

• Variances will be required for the carport expansion and the rear yard.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 10-4-1

712 South Sixth Street

Jan Gordon (Applicant) Alan Patterson (Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-1, 712 South Sixth Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged and deteriorated metal valleys with new metal valleys of appropriate dimension, as necessary. Valleys are to be smooth not a “W” channel to maintain the appropriate historic appearance and profile.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, GAF/Elk Royal Sovereign, self-sealing 3-tab shingles, color to be “Nickel Gray.”

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Hat vents to be removed.

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 10-4-2

188 East Kossuth Street

Jan Gordon (Applicant) Helen Kinnamon (Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-2, 188 East Kossuth Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, GAF/Elk Royal Sovereign, self-sealing 3-tab shingles, color to be “Nickel Gray.”

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Hat vents to be removed.

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 10-4-3

273 East Sycamore Street

Jan Gordon (Applicant) David Schooler (Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-3, 273 East Sycamore Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof on Rear Addition

• The slate roof is to remain on the front portion of the house, as shown on the submitted photographs.

• Remove all existing asphalt shingles from the roof of the house to the rear of the slate roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, GAF/Elk Royal Sovereign, self-sealing 3-tab shingles, color to be “Nickel Gray.”

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Hat vents to be removed.

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 10-4-4

35 Blenkner Street

Stephen D. Stroh Architect, Inc. (Applicant) Pearl of Blenkner Properties, LLC(Owner)

[NOTE: The existing North wall of the property was damaged by a delivery truck collision.]

Approve Application #10-4-4, 35 Blenkner Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Repair Exterior Masonry Wall—North Elevation

• Remove any/all damaged, irreparable masonry and framing items and dispose of per Columbus City Code.

• Retain any/all original, salvageable masonry items and wood windows for reuse and make any/all repairs necessary prior to installation as noted on submitted drawings and as indicated in the Certificate of Appropriateness.

• Save existing divided light, double-hung, wood windows and repair and reinstall like-for-like.

• Prime and paint all exterior wood trim to match existing; Like-for-like.

• Provide and install new sandstone sill to match existing color and profile; like-for-like.

• All work to be as per submitted stamped drawings.

• 10-4-5

631 South Third Street

Superior Home Maintenance (Applicant)/ Great Valley Land Co. (Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-5, 631 South Third Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

• Repair/replace existing balcony on Third Street elevation to match existing, in kind, like-for-like in consultation with the Historic Preservation Office and per submitted specifications.

• All new wood to be painted to match existing.

Exterior Painting

• Paint to match existing color scheme. Any new colors are to be submitted with paint color chips to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval.

• Repair and/or replace all damaged, deteriorated, and missing wood trim elements, as necessary. All replacement wood to be of exact same dimension and profile as the original wood trim; like-for-like, according to industry standards.

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Paint color chips for finish coat are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of the paint.

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• 10-4-6

144 East Kossuth Street

Linda Season (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-6, 144 East Kossuth Street, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Install New Privacy Fence

• Install a new maximum six (6) foot tall wood privacy fence at the rear of the property, per submitted design and siteplan. Fence to be painted or stained within one (1) year.

• 10-4-7

47-47 ½ Thurman Avenue

Juanita Furuta (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-7, 47-47 ½ Thurman Avenue, with all clarifications as indicated.

Renew Certificate of Appropriateness #07-6-43, 47-47 ½ Thurman Avenue, exactly as previously approved for the period of one (1) year. Expired: June 6, 2008.

New Roof , Composite Shingle (Main Roof)

• Remove all deteriorated asphalt shingles on main roof down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self sealing 3-tab shingles. Manufacturer and color to be selected by the owner from the following approved shingles list:

Manufacturer: Color:

[ ] Owens Corning (standard 3-tab) [ ] Estate Gray

• Ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or gray to match the new shingles as closely as possible. Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted in kind.

• 10-4-8

661 South Grant Street

Jamie Weilbacher (Applicant) Dr. Susan Blough (Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-8, 661 South Grant Street, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Repair Slate Roof

• The existing slate roof is to be preserved.

• Replace any/all missing, damaged, and deteriorated slate on the main roof with new or used slate of the exact same color and profile and in accordance with all applicable City Code and industry standards.

Install New Rubber Roof on the Flat Connector Roof

• Remove any/all asphalt shingles or rolled roofing on the flat connector roof down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris in accordance with Columbus City Code.

• Examine all structural members of the flat roofing system from the square (i.e. top plate) to determine condition. Make any/all necessary structural repairs as needed in accordance with standard building practices and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Replace the drip edge on the box gutter adjacent to the rubber roof, as needed.

• Install new E. P. D. M. rubber in accordance with all applicable industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and Columbus Building Codes regarding installation of flat roof coverings.

• Replace any/all deteriorated and damaged wood fascia with new wood of same dimension as necessary. Prime and finish coat all wood fascia prior to the installation of all new gutter and down spouts; color to match the existing trim color. Paint color chip to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all existing asphalt shingles on the north slope of the roof to the south and adjacent to the EDPM rubber roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, self-sealing 3-tab GAF/Elk Slateline shingles, color to be “English Gray Slate.”

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 10-4-9

866 Mohawk Street

Dan Murphy (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-9, 866 Mohawk Street, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Install Handrail

• Install a handrail on the side of the front steps closest to the house, per submitted drawing.

• Rail to be Fortin, style RSS.

• 10-4-10

225 Lear Street

Kimberly & Eric Zipfel (Applicants/Owners)

Approve Application #10-4-10, 225 Lear Street, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Prime all new and bare wood surfaces with the appropriate exterior primer according to manufacturer’s specifications. Finish coat wood surfaces per submitted color schedule, Behr Exterior colors:

• Option A: primary color – “Iron Wood” (ECC-33-1); secondary color – “Ultra Pure White.”

• Option B: primary color – “Quail Ridge” (ECC-18-1); secondary color – “Pebbled Shore” (ECC-18-2).

• Front Door – “Red Hawk” (ECC-46-3) or “Night Tide” (ECC-30-3).

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

• 10-4-11

862 Mohawk Street

Michael J. Cornelis (Applicant) Michael J. Cornelis & Susan A. Riley (Owners)

Approve Application #10-4-11, 862 Mohawk Street, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Exterior Painting

• Prepare all exterior, wooden surfaces on the main house for repainting using the appropriate hand tools.

• Glaze and caulk as necessary.

• Wood siding – “Gargoyle” (1546).

• Wood trim – “Northern Cliffs” (1536).

• Garage Door and other accents – “Iron Mountain” (2134-30).

• Any previously unpainted, masonry (i.e., brick/stone/concrete sills, lintels, porch columns, etc.) is to remain unpainted.

• Any previously painted masonry is to be left as is, or be painted to match the original color of the unpainted masonry as closely as possible.

• Paint color chips for any previously painted masonry are to be submitted to Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to application of paint.

Install New Storm Windows

• Replace ten (10) existing storm windows with new, low profile, metal storm windows.

• New storm windows to be installed inside the existing window frame.

• Storm window color to match the primary trim color as closely as possible.

• Double caulk to provide air-tight installation on top and sides. Do not caulk breather holes.

• Horizontal bar on all new storm windows to align with horizontal sash bar on existing windows.

• Storm windows to operate smoothly.

• All work to be in accordance with the performance manual.

• 10-4-12

752 City Park Avenue

Nat Smith and APCO Industries, Inc. (Applicant) Nat Smith (Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-12, 752 City Park Avenue, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Install New Storm Windows

• Replace five (5) existing storm windows with new, low profile, metal storm windows.

• New storm windows to be installed inside the existing window frame.

• Storm window color to match the primary trim color as closely as possible.

• Double caulk to provide air-tight installation on top and sides. Do not caulk breather holes.

• Horizontal bar on all new storm windows to align with horizontal sash bar on existing windows.

• Storm windows to operate smoothly.

• All work to be in accordance with the performance manual.

• 10-4-13

520 South Fifth Street

Robert Shamansky (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-13, 520 South Fifth Street, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Install New Roof- Rear Two-Story Frame Addition

• Remove any/all asphalt shingles, rolled roofing, tar and/or metal patches on the two story rear frame addition down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Examine the structural members of the roofing system and make any/all necessary structural repairs in accordance with industry standards and all applicable Columbus City Building Codes.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Examine the slope of the original shed roof structure and install the appropriate roofing material and underlayment per industry standards, manufacturer’s specifications, and all applicable Columbus City Building Codes. Color of roofing material to be gray or black. Sample or cut sheet of roofing to be submitted to the Historic Preservation Office staff for final review and approval, prior to installation.

• Replace any/all damaged and deteriorated metal flashing with new metal flashing of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• 10-4-14

251-253 East Blenkner Street

Robert Shamansky (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #10-4-14, 251-253 Blenkner Street, as submitted and with all clarifications as noted:

Repair Roof Rafters

• Examine all structural members of the roofing system to determine condition. Make any/all necessary structural repairs as needed in accordance with standard building practices and all applicable Columbus Building Codes.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing/decking with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• If new roofing shingles are needed, they are to match the existing roof.

VII. NEW BUSINESS

VIII. OLD BUSINESS

IX. ADJOURNMENT

Commission Agenda 03/02/10

jgraichen — Thu, 25 Feb 2010 14:19:31 +0000

GERMAN VILLAGE COMMISSION AGENDA

March 2, 2010

4:00 p.m.

German Village Meeting Haus – 588 S. Third Street

I. CALL TO ORDER

II. NEXT MONTHLY BUSINESS MEETING – 12:00 PM (NOON), Tuesday, February 23, 2010.

109 N FRONT ST., FIRST FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM.

III. NEXT COMMISSION HEARING – TUESDAY, April 6, 2010.

IV. APPROVAL OF REGULAR MEETING MINUTES, Tuesday, February 2, 2010.

V. PUBLIC FORUM

VI. APPLICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS

CONTINUED APPLICATIONS

1. 10-2-14

376 East Beck Street

William Hugus Architects, Ltd. (Applicant)/ George Lekorenos (Owner)

Continued from the February 2, 2010 German Village Commission Meeting.

• Construct two (2) new gabled dormers on east elevation of existing brick cottage per submitted drawings.

• Dormers to will replace the existing two (2) skylights.

• These dormers will match the future GVC approved addition dormers, which is unbuilt as of 1-19-10.

WITHDRAWN BY APPLICANT

NEW APPLICATIONS

2. 10-3-9

369 Berger Alley

MCM Home Builders (Applicant) Gayle Strege (Owner)

An application and photographs have been submitted.

• Move rear door and add four (4) 30” x 44” six-over-six all wood interior/exterior double-hung wood windows to the rear elevation.

• The proposed windows will match windows approved in application #10-1-4 for replacement of the second story windows.

CONCEPTUAL REVIEW APPLICATIONS

3. 10-3-10

85 East Deshler Avenue

Janet Ward Druen (Applicant/Owner)

An application and photographs have been submitted.

Conceptual Review

• Add a one-over-one double-hung window and stone lintel, size to match adjacent windows, on the south side of the second floor at the rear of the house.

• The proposed additional window and lintel stone were removed from the first floor of the house when the addition was added to the rear of the house.

NEW APPLICATIONS

4. 10-3-11

792 South Fifth Street

Forrest Gibson (Applicant) Rich & Janet Dawson (Owners)

An application, photographs and drawings have been submitted.

• Construct a garage per submitted drawings.

STAFF APPROVALS

(The following applicants do not need to attend the hearing)

• 10-3-1

543 Mohawk Street

John Space (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #10-3-1, 543 Mohawk Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Renew Certificate of Appropriateness

Renew Certificate of Appropriateness #08-10-18, 543 Mohawk Street, exactly as previously approved for the period of one (1) year. Expired: October 7, 2009.

Recommend approval of the proposed variance for the property located at 543 Mohawk Street, as submitted:

• 3332.14R-2F – reduce conforming lot size from 6000-sqft to 2224-sqft.

• 3332.27 – Reduce rear yard percentage from 25% to 3.1%.

• 3332.26 – Reduce minimum side yard of a lot 40-ft wide or less from 3-ft to 2-ft.

• 3342.15 – Reduce parking space maneuvering from 20-ft to 18-ft.

• 3342.28A6 – Reduce minimum parking spaces for single –family from 2 spaces to 1 space.

MOTION: Panzer/Thiell (6-0-0) RECOMMEND APPROVAL.

• 10-3-2

543 Mohawk Street

John Space (Applicant/Owner)

Approve Application #10-3-2, 543 Mohawk Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Renew Certificate of Appropriateness

Renew Certificate of Appropriateness #08-2-14, 543 Mohawk Street, exactly as previously approved for the period of one (1) year. Expired: April 1, 2009.

Approve Application #08-2-14, 543 Mohawk Street with the following stipulations:

• Construction of a new addition on rear/ west elevation per submitted drawings.

• The proposed steps of the rear addition to be cut limestone steps.

• The proposed transoms on the rear elevation of the addition as presented in the drawings to be deleted and two double hung windows will be added one over another at the left side of the rear elevation; a square 30×30” window will be added at the stair landing. Revised drawings to be submitted for review and approval.

• All eave and trim details will match the German Village guidelines, page # 78.

• Final revised drawings must be submitted to the HPO staff for final review and approval.

Motion: Panzer/ Thiell (6-0-0) APPROVAL

• 10-3-3

44 Stimmel Street

Superior Home Maintenance (Applicant) John Wahling (Owner)

Approve Application #10-3-3, 44 Stimmel Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof on Rear Addition

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the rear addition, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, CertainTeed, self-sealing 3-tab shingles, color to be “Nickel Grey.”

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Hat vents to be removed.

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 10-3-4

1145 South Fourth Street

Jan Gordon (Applicant) Keith Knopf (Owner)

Approve Application #10-3-4, 1145 South Fourth Street, with all clarifications as indicated.

Remove and Install New Asphalt Shingle Roof

• Remove all asphalt shingles on the main roof, down to the sheathing. Dispose of all debris according to Columbus City Code.

• Replace any/all damaged, deteriorated, and missing sheathing with wood of appropriate dimension, as necessary.

• Install new, 30 lb. felt paper on all sheathing according to manufacturer’s specifications.

• Replace any/all damaged metal flashing on all existing chimneys.

• Install new 235 lb., class C, GAF/ELK Royal Sovereign self-sealing 3-tab shingles, color to be “Nickel Gray.”

• All ridges to be capped with galvanized metal ridge roll, in lieu of cut shingle tabs, and painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Upon completion, all metal valleys and flashing are to be painted “Tinner’s Red” or “Gray.”

• Any/all necessary venting is to be performed on the roof ridge, underneath the metal ridge roll via CobraVent, VentSure, or comparable, in lieu of hat-vents.

• 10-3-5

200 Reinhard Avenue

Jan Gordon (Applicant) Ira Sully (Owner)

Approve Application #10-3-5, 200 Reinhard Avenue, with all clarifications as indicated.